Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Pretty Sick of Americans (2)

I am a big fan of public education.

I am not a fan of the public school system.

For a good portion of my professional career—from 1991 until last year—I was pretty active in Delaware’s (and, by extension, the nation’s) “educational reform” efforts.

Sometimes I feel like singing that old song:

Look what they’ve done to my song, Ma!
Look what they’ve done to my song!
Well it’s the only thing I could do half right,
And it’s turning out all wrong, Ma!
Look what they’ve done to my song!


I am a fan of public education because a free and democratic society needs an educated citizenry, and education needs to be available to every citizen regardless of his (or her) ability to pay (or the parents’ ability to pay).

I support President Obama’s intention for “health care reform” for the same reason. If access to doctors and nurses and medicines isn’t a right in the same way that access to schools and teachers and books is, then it should be. When the signers of the Declaration of Independence asserted all humankind’s “inalienable rights …[to] life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness,” wouldn’t they have considered health care as appropriately necessary to two of those three rights?

Life without health…

Pursuit of happiness without health…

Note the paradoxes?

Now, the reason we have public education is that, back in 1787, when James Madison, George Washington, and all those guys were in Philadelphia hammering out the Constitution, many of them were afraid of establishing “too democratic” a government because they feared that the uneducated masses would not really be able to govern themselves. It may have been a legitimate fear because the average American had, like, a third-grade education. How could people who understood little more than the need for rain to make their crops grow be expected to decide on how to conduct the nation’s affairs—like wars, foreign trade, etc.?

So they gave us a Democratic Republic instead of a True Democracy. But they also developed a vision in which the average American would one day be educated to the point of being able to participate in the larger, more complex affairs of state. An uneducated citizenry, Jefferson wrote on more than one occasion, was easy prey for demagogues who would seize on the people’s fears and passions in order to rise to power. Thus, the concept of public education was born, and the public school system began to evolve. (Here’s one link out of many about all the stuff Jefferson wrote about public education.)

Probably the biggest reason Jefferson, et. al. didn’t deal with health care to any extent is because there was no health care in the eighteenth century! George Washington swallowed mercury pills like candy, and, when he died in 1799, the main cause of his death was the practice of “blood-letting” and the dangerous amount he had been “bled.”

In the absence of anything even remotely resembling “health care,” it is no wonder the Founders did not consider it a right and a necessity for the citizenry of their new republic.

But if they were alive today, would they consider a healthy citizenry necessary for the perpetuation of Liberty…? I believe so.

And this is why I’m getting pretty sick of Americans—because we’ve allowed ourselves to fall prey to demagogues who (if you’ll pardon the expression), talk about of both sides of their mouths, saying whatever they think we want them to say so that they can maintain power. And we don’t call them on it!

Back in the 1990s, when everyone was running around wanting educational reform, one of the ideas proposed by those with right-leaning tendencies was “vouchers.” “Vouchers” would allow parents to take their sons’ and daughters’ share of the public school “pot” and use that money to pay private school tuition.

Opponents argued that taking public funds away from public schools would cripple school budgets and weaken, perhaps even destroy, the public schools—especially in poorer areas in which the schools were already strapped for cash.

Proponents of vouchers argued that the “competition” would be good for the public schools: make them work harder and more efficiently to attract and keep their students—make them better schools.

(Twenty years later, there is much more evidence to suggest that vouchers, while they did not destroy the public schools, certainly did little to improve the educations of students who attended private school on taxpayers’ nickel.)

Transition back to 2009 and the health care debate, and we have the same situation, the same arguments, and the same rhetoric only the sides have changed…

Those on the “right,” who argued that competition would be good for public schools, who said that using public money to subsidize private school tuition would improve public education are now the exact same people who are saying that the competition of a “public option” would put private insurance companies out of business. (After all, who’d pay for overpriced and undervalued private insurance if I can get my health care for free? Uh, maybe the same people who—for any number of reasons—opt to pay private school tuition instead of sending their children to the free neighborhood public school.)

Those on the “left” insist that the competition will be good for the private companies—make them more honest, more efficient.

Do the demagogues on both sides of the aisle have so little memory (or do they pay so little attention to their own rhetoric) that they don’t realize their own inconsistencies? And do we, the American people, have such short memories that we cannot remind our elected officials of their previous views and the rightness or wrongness of those views…?

I’m getting really sick of Americans.

I am a big fan of public education. I believe that every American—regardless of race, gender, income, geographic location, whatever—has a fundamental right to an education in order to participate fully and knowingly in the workings of our free and open society.

That the public education system is too politicized, bloated, wasteful, and inefficient is another argument for another day.

By the same token, I wholeheartedly support any legislation that will give every American access to medical treatment. I believe it is a part of our inalienable rights to life and the pursuit of happiness to maintain our physical and mental health. I believe our Founders would have thought so too, had anything like health care existed in their day.

But I’m getting tired of the debate—as if a debate like this had never been held before. I’m getting tired of demagogues (on both sides) preying on people’s fears and biases to gain a few points in a popularity poll or garner a few more votes in the next election. I’m getting tired of short-sighted and short-minded politicians scratching their heads, unable to think of a cohesive system—as if there were no precedents for private/public concerns operating parallel to one another and at times even interacting with and helping one another.

And I’m getting pretty sick Americans’ allowing themselves to be duped by these demagogues, pandered to by politicians, and falling far short of the type of educated and vigilant citizenry Madison, Jefferson, and Washington probably envisioned the United States of America would have by the first decade of the twenty-first century!

No comments:

Post a Comment