Monday, April 27, 2009

Let's Hear It for School Prayer!

I’ve been thinking a lot about school prayer. I think we should have it.

Now, I’m not taking about prayer in school. Because we’ve always had that. There’ve always been the kids who sit at their table in the cafeteria, hold hands, and say some form of grace before eating their peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. There’ve always been the kids who maybe cross themselves (or whatever their ritual or tradition might be), close their eyes, and mouth a little prayer before their final exam.

I don’t know of any who have been burnt at the stake for having a private, little moment of communion with their deity. They might get stared at; some of their less-enlightened classmates might make an ignorant comment to them, but that’s another issue for another day (“10Blessed are they that are persecuted for righteousness’ sake...11Blessed are ye when men shall revile you …” Matthew 5: 10-11).

Personally, I’ve always thought that the people who complained that they “couldn’t pray” at any given time or place probably weren’t very strong pray-ers to begin with.

But I’m talking about mandated school prayer. I think we should have it. I think we should all write and call our state legislators and demand it. Constitution be damned, every kid in every public school should be required to pray at least once a day.

Given the proper legislation, mandatory, organized school prayer—that so many people on Fox News and the Internet seem to want—could be fully instituted in a month or less.

Here’s a model we could follow:

The Islamic faith has five obligated prayer times, one of which—the noon prayer—occurs during the school day, so this is the one we will adopt. Since the First Amendment guarantees all Muslim students the right to the “free exercise” of their religion, since they have a noon-prayer obligation, and since the supporters of school prayer don’t seem to think there’s any harm in forcing kids to participate in prayer rituals foreign to their own, no one should object to a mandatory noon-prayer break. (Okay, granted, there are those liberals who say that kids who “choose not to participate” in the prayer can absent themselves, so we’ll let those who choose not to participate in this mandatory prayer stand in the hallways or something.)

Booklets explaining the appropriate postures and teaching the words and pronunciations can be distributed in English and social studies classes, and the proper attire can be made available from either the school nurse or the guidance department. With diligence and consistency, within a month, the practice of pausing at noon for organized prayer can be well established in every public school from sea to shining sea.

Of course, it just occurred to me that there might be those with…uh…narrow perspectives, who would object to Islamic prayer in school. We won’t go into what their objections might be, let’s just know that there might be objections—this is America, after all. In that case, we could surely distribute blue and white prayer shawls and yarmulkes to all the students. Again, booklets containing the prayers can be printed up and distributed in English and social studies classes. Students and teachers can spend a few days drilling the pronunciation and intonations, and again, full participation in organized school prayer could be achieved in a month—or less. (Again, students who had an objection to participating in Jewish prayer could report to the main office during the ritual.)

Come to think of it, though, it seems the vast, vast majority of those clamoring about school prayer identify themselves as Christians, so it might be that they want organized Christian prayer in school, not just any random spiritual communion with a deity.

No matter, this will actually be easier, because at least the kids’ll be able to pray in English. (We’d have to teach the non-English-speaking kids to recite the words from memory because I doubt the school-praying Christians would want their kids’ ears polluted with prayers in, say, Spanish or anything…

Again, though, the English teacher can be responsible for teaching the prayers, and the guidance office can distribute the rosary beads. The physical education teacher can spend a little time teaching the kids how to make the sign of the cross properly. This all should take even less than a month.

So I’m all for it. Let’s have “prayer in school.” Let’s mandate organized school prayer. What is there to lose?

But, I think I still hear a lot of people complaining that none of the above is what they meant at all. They don’t want prayer. Not really. Not if “prayer” means wearing funny clothes, mumbling in some foreign language, or fiddling with beads. They want “real prayer,” and what they mean by “real prayer,” is of course, the kind of prayer that they do.

In church (not in a synagogue or—gasp—a mosque).

On Sunday (not Saturday or Friday).

They don’t want a moment of quiet spirituality, they want kids participating in their particular brand of religion. And if that’s what they want, then, sorry, I can’t help them. I wouldn’t want to force the Friend to utter his prayers aloud any more than I’d want to snatch rosaries out of the Catholic’s hand or the yarmulke off the Jew’s head.

Prayer is private. Jesus tells his followers to keep it private (“And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men... But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen...” Matthew 6:5-6)

The drafters of the Constitution (or at least of the Bill of Rights) understood the very private nature of one’s faith and one’s expression of that faith, and they deemed that the government would never force a Christian to pray like a Jew or a Muslim like a Christian. I think they also meant that an atheist should not be forced to pray at all.

If you honestly feel that there are times when, and places where, you cannot pray; if you honestly feel you cannot pray without benefit of a court order or federal statute, what does that say about you? What does that say about what you claim to be your faith? What does it say about your relationship with your deity?

Not much, I think.

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

The Ugly Truth

Well, for a couple of weeks, the entire world seems to have fallen in love with Susan Boyle, the 47-year-old Brit, who stunned everyone with her performance of “I Dreamed a Dream” on Britain’s Got Talent.

Well, not the entire world because the blogosphere is rife with commentaries both praising and panning the woman, her performance, her appearance, the fact that the performance was “staged” or prearranged, and on and on and on...

And, of course, many commentators have picked up the opportunity to criticize “the media” and its skewed values (from the fact that the program was edited, to the fact that Simon Cowell “knew” a woman like Susan Boyle would strike a chord with the general public.)

A couple of things have bothered me about everyone’s reaction.

First of all, I’m bothered that the word ugly has reared its ugly head. Some references mean “ugly” in the sense of “ugly duckling,” while others simply mean “ugly.” I have a problem with both usages.

Let’s face it, the ugly duckling was ugly. As the story goes, he/she/it didn’t possess a beauty that no one noticed or appreciated, he/she/it grew into its beauty. Apparently swan chicks (actually they’re called cygnets) are ugly. So, even appreciating the use of “ugly” as a hyperbole for the sake of an “ugly duckling” metaphor, it’s still grossly unjust to call the woman “ugly.”

In addition, there are those who have simply called the woman ugly. She’s not. She’s really quite average looking. I am reminded of a short play by A. A. Milne of Winnie the Pooh fame. (By the way, I discovered only a few months ago, that Milne was a man. I also learned that his son, Christopher Robin hated him.) Anyway, this play is called “The Ugly Duckling,” and it’s about an “ugly” princess who makes her beautiful maid pretend to be her to court her beautiful suitor. It turns out that the real prince is the “ugly” page. Plain prince and gorgeous page have also switched places in order to woo the princess.

The point of the play is that neither the princess nor the prince is really ugly; they are average-looking. Compared, however, to their fairy-tale-princess-and-prince peers, they are “ugly.” The princess had been granted her ugliness as a gift at her christening by her fairy godmother. If the princess were ugly, the fairy godmother knew, the girl would not grow up pampered and spoiled.

(Anyone see a connection—metaphoric or otherwise—with our society’s powerful Cult of Celebrity, our idolization of “beauty,” and then our dismissal of “average”? It’s almost a powerful enough trend to contribute to young women’s and men’s poor self-images and cause them to develop eating disorders and exercise obsessions, and...oh, wait...)

Anyway, what’s all this got to do with Susan Boyle? Well, like it not, we do base many of our personal judgments on appearance. Shows like 20/20 and Dateline have run a number of episodes over the years about the impact of weight, physical attractiveness, age, dress, etc., on how people are treated in public situations.

The other problem I have with our reaction to Ms. Boyle is how we blame the media for the values both supporters and detractors see exemplified in the whole episode.

The media focuses only on physical appearance and has conditioned us to believe that the average-looking have no value.

The media manipulates us psychologically and emotionally. Susan Boyle was prescreened, and the producers of Britain’s Got Talent (aka Simon Cowell) knew exactly what she would sing and that she would sing it beautifully. The entire segment was edited to highlight the Cinderella-beauty-in-plainness aspect and tug at the heartstrings of the world.

Shame on the media.

I’d like to address the second criticism first. My response is...du-uhhhhh... Of course the performance was screened and the segment edited. That’s what the media does. That’s what we want them to do! Theoretically, the reason we watch television, go to the movies, read books, whatever, is to be “surprised, amused, and delighted.” (Well, I guess there are some people who do watch some news programs with the intent of having their biases and prejudices confirmed rather than challenged, but that is another argument for another day.)

If the media does exactly what we want it to do, and does it all too well, we should not moan and whine, we should applaud!

My response to the first criticism is an extension of this idea. The media is not an entity unto itself; it is a tool, a mirror. Only a fool blames the mirror because he doesn’t like the reflection. So, if we feel convicted because our first inclination was to laugh at this dowdy, middle-aged woman and dismiss the possibility that she might have talent, then that is our conviction. The media only held up the mirror. (I mean, if the media were the least bit interested in shaping society’s values as opposed to merely pandering to them, we would see a lot more originality and a lot less imitation. Eighteen months from now, how many iterations of the “Susan Boyle” phenomenon do you think every broadcast network in the free world will have given us?)

As the Ghost of Christmas Past tells Ebenezer Scrooge in my all-time favorite book, “These are the shadows of things that have been. That they are what they are, do not blame me.”

Imagine the media telling us, “These are the reflections of your attitudes, values, and beliefs. That they are what they are, do not blame us.”

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

America: Home of the Copycat

Right now, I’m reading Ayn Rand’s The Fountainhead. I don’t really know why; probably because I was looking for a book to read, and “it was there.”

Actually, this is the second time I’ve started this book. I picked it up a few months ago and then put it down to read Alan Paton’s Cry the Beloved Country, which I didn’t read in twelfth-grade English (you know how that goes). When I started …Fountainhead, the first time, the novel annoyed me. Rand has all this “stuff” to say about architecture and modernism versus traditionalism (she’s clearly on the side of modernism). Several of her characters rant about architectural theory. One particularly pompous dunce spouts something to the effect that everything beautiful has already been created; the principles of beauty have already been established, and today’s artists have nothing to do but manipulate them into new arrangements.

As I say, I grew impatient with the book and Rand’s obvious social/philosophical point.

Then I got to thinking about something that has been bothering me for years: why, in our society, do we accept imitation at the expense of innovation? We claim to value creativity in school—in fact, some have argued that we value “creativity” at the expense of “basics.” But that’s another argument for another day.

Still, what evidence can we produce to support our claim that, in society, we really value creativity?

Of the top 10 movies that opened last week (April 10, 2009), and the top 10 hyped as “Coming Soon,” one is the 92nd iteration of the adult-in-kid-body-revisit-the-past-to-change-the-future theme, four are franchise movies (the fourth, or fifth, or fiftieth films in endless series), and three are based on already-popular television series (one a BBC import). Eight of the twenty (40%) reflect more a decision to recycle what is already successful than to test the boundary and encourage creativity.

Broadway is worse. Of the thirty-two plays currently running (or opening within the next few weeks), thirteen (41%) are revivals of previously successful plays. Seven are plays or stage musicals based on already-popular movies. Three are “juke-box musicals” for which storylines were built around already-popular music. And one is a musical based on a popular book based on an even-more popular movie based on a popular series of books. Of thirty-two plays, only eight (25%) are original, first-run offerings by living, breathing, creative playwrights. Of course, that’s an improvement over recent years when none of the Great White Way’s offerings were new. (One was sort-of new, but it had already proven successful in the UK, so it was safe to bring over here.)

And let’s not even start to talk about television. How many “American” TV shows are simply low-quality “adaptations” of popular British shows? How many seasons of The Bachelor and American Idol (which, I believe, is also a British import), and The Apprentice must we sit through? How long can the networks continue to imitate themselves and each other before the once-rich soil is thoroughly depleted, and nothing will grow except re-runs of CSI and House (come to think of it, we’re practically already there)?

I don’t know why this is bothering me now. Maybe it is because the Ayn Rand novel has got me to thinking. Maybe because it’s April, the month during which Hans Christian Andersen, Henry James, Eudora Welty, and William Shakespeare were all born (okay, so Shakespeare recycled most of his plots from classical mythology…but Samuel Beckett, another April playwright, was pretty creative—and he’s currently got a play running on Broadway).

Whatever the reason, it’s something to think about. I’d hate to think that the pompous dean of Rand’s fictional Stanton Institute of Technology is right, that everything has already been created, and all that’s left is to imitate and rearrange.

But I see so little evidence to the contrary these days.