I am a big fan of public education.
I am not a fan of the public school system.
For a good portion of my professional career—from 1991 until last year—I was pretty active in Delaware’s (and, by extension, the nation’s) “educational reform” efforts.
Sometimes I feel like singing that old song:
Look what they’ve done to my song, Ma!
Look what they’ve done to my song!
Well it’s the only thing I could do half right,
And it’s turning out all wrong, Ma!
Look what they’ve done to my song!
I am a fan of public education because a free and democratic society needs an educated citizenry, and education needs to be available to every citizen regardless of his (or her) ability to pay (or the parents’ ability to pay).
I support President Obama’s intention for “health care reform” for the same reason. If access to doctors and nurses and medicines isn’t a right in the same way that access to schools and teachers and books is, then it should be. When the signers of the Declaration of Independence asserted all humankind’s “inalienable rights …[to] life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness,” wouldn’t they have considered health care as appropriately necessary to two of those three rights?
Life without health…
Pursuit of happiness without health…
Note the paradoxes?
Now, the reason we have public education is that, back in 1787, when James Madison, George Washington, and all those guys were in Philadelphia hammering out the Constitution, many of them were afraid of establishing “too democratic” a government because they feared that the uneducated masses would not really be able to govern themselves. It may have been a legitimate fear because the average American had, like, a third-grade education. How could people who understood little more than the need for rain to make their crops grow be expected to decide on how to conduct the nation’s affairs—like wars, foreign trade, etc.?
So they gave us a Democratic Republic instead of a True Democracy. But they also developed a vision in which the average American would one day be educated to the point of being able to participate in the larger, more complex affairs of state. An uneducated citizenry, Jefferson wrote on more than one occasion, was easy prey for demagogues who would seize on the people’s fears and passions in order to rise to power. Thus, the concept of public education was born, and the public school system began to evolve. (Here’s one link out of many about all the stuff Jefferson wrote about public education.)
Probably the biggest reason Jefferson, et. al. didn’t deal with health care to any extent is because there was no health care in the eighteenth century! George Washington swallowed mercury pills like candy, and, when he died in 1799, the main cause of his death was the practice of “blood-letting” and the dangerous amount he had been “bled.”
In the absence of anything even remotely resembling “health care,” it is no wonder the Founders did not consider it a right and a necessity for the citizenry of their new republic.
But if they were alive today, would they consider a healthy citizenry necessary for the perpetuation of Liberty…? I believe so.
And this is why I’m getting pretty sick of Americans—because we’ve allowed ourselves to fall prey to demagogues who (if you’ll pardon the expression), talk about of both sides of their mouths, saying whatever they think we want them to say so that they can maintain power. And we don’t call them on it!
Back in the 1990s, when everyone was running around wanting educational reform, one of the ideas proposed by those with right-leaning tendencies was “vouchers.” “Vouchers” would allow parents to take their sons’ and daughters’ share of the public school “pot” and use that money to pay private school tuition.
Opponents argued that taking public funds away from public schools would cripple school budgets and weaken, perhaps even destroy, the public schools—especially in poorer areas in which the schools were already strapped for cash.
Proponents of vouchers argued that the “competition” would be good for the public schools: make them work harder and more efficiently to attract and keep their students—make them better schools.
(Twenty years later, there is much more evidence to suggest that vouchers, while they did not destroy the public schools, certainly did little to improve the educations of students who attended private school on taxpayers’ nickel.)
Transition back to 2009 and the health care debate, and we have the same situation, the same arguments, and the same rhetoric only the sides have changed…
Those on the “right,” who argued that competition would be good for public schools, who said that using public money to subsidize private school tuition would improve public education are now the exact same people who are saying that the competition of a “public option” would put private insurance companies out of business. (After all, who’d pay for overpriced and undervalued private insurance if I can get my health care for free? Uh, maybe the same people who—for any number of reasons—opt to pay private school tuition instead of sending their children to the free neighborhood public school.)
Those on the “left” insist that the competition will be good for the private companies—make them more honest, more efficient.
Do the demagogues on both sides of the aisle have so little memory (or do they pay so little attention to their own rhetoric) that they don’t realize their own inconsistencies? And do we, the American people, have such short memories that we cannot remind our elected officials of their previous views and the rightness or wrongness of those views…?
I’m getting really sick of Americans.
I am a big fan of public education. I believe that every American—regardless of race, gender, income, geographic location, whatever—has a fundamental right to an education in order to participate fully and knowingly in the workings of our free and open society.
That the public education system is too politicized, bloated, wasteful, and inefficient is another argument for another day.
By the same token, I wholeheartedly support any legislation that will give every American access to medical treatment. I believe it is a part of our inalienable rights to life and the pursuit of happiness to maintain our physical and mental health. I believe our Founders would have thought so too, had anything like health care existed in their day.
But I’m getting tired of the debate—as if a debate like this had never been held before. I’m getting tired of demagogues (on both sides) preying on people’s fears and biases to gain a few points in a popularity poll or garner a few more votes in the next election. I’m getting tired of short-sighted and short-minded politicians scratching their heads, unable to think of a cohesive system—as if there were no precedents for private/public concerns operating parallel to one another and at times even interacting with and helping one another.
And I’m getting pretty sick Americans’ allowing themselves to be duped by these demagogues, pandered to by politicians, and falling far short of the type of educated and vigilant citizenry Madison, Jefferson, and Washington probably envisioned the United States of America would have by the first decade of the twenty-first century!
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Pretty Sick of Americans (1)
You know, I’m getting pretty sick of Americans.
I won’t say I’m getting sick of America, because the nation—as explained and defined in the Declaration of Independence, Constitution (including the Bill of Rights), the presidential addresses of such notables as Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, John Kennedy, and Barack Obama—is still a good concept. It’s a high ideal. It’s a Truth (with a capital “T”).
But Americans seem to be doing everything in their power either to make damn sure the idea does not come to fruition, or to destroy it outright.
The sad thing is, Americans are destroying their own nation, not out of love of a new ideal they’d like to see instead, but out of sheer stupidity.
From what I’ve seen and read in recent days, weeks, months, years…, Americans do not think before they speak. They do not listen to themselves when they are speaking. And they do not remember for more than five minutes what they said after they’re done speaking.
(And forget about listening to someone else in polite, respectful dialogue.)
Take the current “controversy” over President Obama’s address to the nation’s school children on Tuesday (September 8—the day after Labor Day and a traditional day for the start of a new school year).
First of all, what is more appropriate than the President of the United States addressing the youth of the nation on the first day of school? It should be a Constitutional requirement, not a source of contention!!!!!
Second, there are those who say they were afraid that the President’s address would be some form of indoctrination, that he would try to foist “his political agenda” on the vulnerable minds of the nation’s youth. Do these whiners not realize that, whatever Candidate Obama’s “agenda” was before the election, it became the nation’s agenda the day after the election? It was, after all the agenda the nation chose by electing him!!!!!!! (And, yes, he is your president, even if you did not vote for him, just as the Other Guy was my president for eight years…)
Third, I’ve heard and read so many “pundits” (and I have to look up that word because I honestly do not know what it means) throw around words like “Socialist,” “Communist,” “Indoctrination,” and I’m not sure these “pundits” have any idea what they’re talking about either. The public school system is a socialist institution. Citizens pay taxes, and taxes support the schools—buy the books, pay the teachers and principals…etc. And every child in the country has the right to attend regardless of income or social standing. I think that’s Socialism.
So I don’t think the pundits are really worried about “Socialism” as much as they fear “Tyranny” or “Totalitarianism.”
The public school system is neither of these because there are legal alternatives to the public school system. Any parent who fears that his or her child will be “indoctrinated” by the “evil socialist education-regime” has the legal right to send his or her children to private school—schools sponsored by and affiliated with any number of private concerns and religions! To go further, if you still can’t find a school you like (public or private), you have the legal right to keep your kids home and teach them yourselves!
(Ironically, the clearest model of indoctrination I can think of is to keep a person hostage, isolated from the larger society, expose him/her only to party-approved ideas, carefully select and screen everything he/she reads, every television or other media message he/she receives, and threaten him/her with punishment or excommunication if he/she dares to consider an opposing or divergent viewpoint and fail to spout the party line.)
—Sorry if I offend, but if the shoe fits…
Anyway, back to point the Third: as education has always been the right and responsibility of the States (as opposed to the Federal Government, except in cases in which the state has failed to protect an individual’s right to an education…), and as most of the states allow for local control of public schools, it was made clear well in advance that every district, every school, even every individual teacher was free to choose whether or not to air the address. No one was required to show it. No one was required to watch it. Absolutely no penalties were threatened or imposed on anyone who chose to do a Seek-and-Find or a Sudoku instead. So, claims of “Socialism”—when they really mean “tyranny” or “totalitarianism” anyway—simply don’t hold up. Not when you can legally opt out, without penalty.
Finally, I have heard so many parents—and even some teachers—express “concern” about the “lesson plans” that were offered online by the U.S. Department of Education.
*gasp!*
These “lesson plans” included such indoctrinary and subversive activities as (and these are direct quotations from the DOE website:
http://www.ed.gov/teachers/how/lessons/prek-6.pdf and http://www.ed.gov/teachers/how/lessons/7-12.pdf ):
Having students discuss before the speech:
• Who is the President of the United States?
• To whom do you think the president is going to be speaking?
• Why do you think he wants to speak to you?
• What do you think he will say to you?
OMG! Before even listening to the speech, these indoctrinators want our students to consider the speaker, the audience, the supposed purpose of the speech, and the predicted content… (But, wait, doesn’t that sound like the “motivational activities” from any reading or listening lesson in any textbook from any of the big textbook companies?)
After the speech, it was suggested that:
“Teachers could ask students to share the ideas they recorded…”
(Holy Cow! First they were asked to take notes during the speech and now to share their ideas with other students…?)
“… to discuss main ideas from the speech, such as citizenship, personal responsibility, and civic duty.”
(So are we in favor of these things or opposed to them? I get so confused…! If we’re opposed to modeling good citizenship and teaching civic responsibility to our kids, we should probably stop having school governments, mock elections, Boys and Girls States, American Legion essay contests, etc. After all, we don’t want our kids “indoctrinated” with dangerous ideas…)
One of the final discussion questions in the K-6 guide is,
“What would you like to tell the president?”
Can any whiner or detractor please tell me what model of totalitarian tyranny (which the whiners and detractors still mistakenly call “socialism”) allows young children to respond to a message from the regime-leader?
And if we’re really worried about indoctrination through “free” lesson plans, consider the volume of “educational” materials put out by Coke and Pepsi and sporting goods companies, banks and insurance companies, etc., etc., etc. Consider the coloring books, works sheets, crossword puzzles, story pamphlets “made available” by groups like the NRA, the ALA, the NCTE and IRA, not to mention the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines (and all of their respective ROTCs), all of which have “agendas” they wish to advance through their “free” materials. And don’t forget that private and commercial enterprises are not in any way accountable to the voter and taxpayer the way a government agency like the Department of Education is!
In sum, it seems that we have whiners and complainers whining and complaining about the facts that:
• an elected representative of the People spoke to a portion of those people;
• some of those people apparently do not understand the difference between personal concerns and public concerns, and they do not understand what it means to elect a “representative”;
• some of these same people do not have sufficient vocabulary to frame and articulate their vague concerns in a way that others might understand;
• they do not understand that actions they consider potentially dangerous to their children are already being performed and have been performed for decades by entities far more insidious and far less accountable than an elected representative of the people.
It kind of makes me shake my head in sorrow. I don’t care whether you like the current president or not. I don’t care whether you didn’t vote for him to begin with, or whether you did vote for him and are now disillusioned. I don’t care whether you have kids in public school, private school, or home school. I don’t care whether your kids are adults and already out of school. I don’t care whether your kids are toddlers and not yet in school. I don’t care whether you live in a “red” state or a “blue” state or a state of confusion. I don’t care what your race is, or your gender, or your ethnic heritage, or your religious affiliation, or your income, or your height or weight or hair and eye color. I don’t care whether you’re right- or left-handed, have warts on your toes, or wear eyeglasses. None of these things is an excuse for being stupid.
And I do care if you’re stupid. I do care if you throw around words without knowing what they mean. I do care if you criticize the “other” without knowing what that “other” is.
I do care when you intentionally misrepresent that “other” in order to criticize it (see Exodus 20: 16 and Deuteronomy 5: 20—something about “bear[ing] false witness...”).
I do care if you’re too lazy to verify someone else’s criticism of something you don’t understand yourself (talk about indoctrination!).
And I do care if you create and support a double standard in which X can do something but Y cannot.
And, for all the hubbub, what did President Obama tell the kids? What was his great, socialist agenda?
…Work hard in school because you’ll need your education later on.
How dare he!
So, America, you’re a good idea. But Americans, you need to grow up!
I won’t say I’m getting sick of America, because the nation—as explained and defined in the Declaration of Independence, Constitution (including the Bill of Rights), the presidential addresses of such notables as Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, John Kennedy, and Barack Obama—is still a good concept. It’s a high ideal. It’s a Truth (with a capital “T”).
But Americans seem to be doing everything in their power either to make damn sure the idea does not come to fruition, or to destroy it outright.
The sad thing is, Americans are destroying their own nation, not out of love of a new ideal they’d like to see instead, but out of sheer stupidity.
From what I’ve seen and read in recent days, weeks, months, years…, Americans do not think before they speak. They do not listen to themselves when they are speaking. And they do not remember for more than five minutes what they said after they’re done speaking.
(And forget about listening to someone else in polite, respectful dialogue.)
Take the current “controversy” over President Obama’s address to the nation’s school children on Tuesday (September 8—the day after Labor Day and a traditional day for the start of a new school year).
First of all, what is more appropriate than the President of the United States addressing the youth of the nation on the first day of school? It should be a Constitutional requirement, not a source of contention!!!!!
Second, there are those who say they were afraid that the President’s address would be some form of indoctrination, that he would try to foist “his political agenda” on the vulnerable minds of the nation’s youth. Do these whiners not realize that, whatever Candidate Obama’s “agenda” was before the election, it became the nation’s agenda the day after the election? It was, after all the agenda the nation chose by electing him!!!!!!! (And, yes, he is your president, even if you did not vote for him, just as the Other Guy was my president for eight years…)
Third, I’ve heard and read so many “pundits” (and I have to look up that word because I honestly do not know what it means) throw around words like “Socialist,” “Communist,” “Indoctrination,” and I’m not sure these “pundits” have any idea what they’re talking about either. The public school system is a socialist institution. Citizens pay taxes, and taxes support the schools—buy the books, pay the teachers and principals…etc. And every child in the country has the right to attend regardless of income or social standing. I think that’s Socialism.
So I don’t think the pundits are really worried about “Socialism” as much as they fear “Tyranny” or “Totalitarianism.”
The public school system is neither of these because there are legal alternatives to the public school system. Any parent who fears that his or her child will be “indoctrinated” by the “evil socialist education-regime” has the legal right to send his or her children to private school—schools sponsored by and affiliated with any number of private concerns and religions! To go further, if you still can’t find a school you like (public or private), you have the legal right to keep your kids home and teach them yourselves!
(Ironically, the clearest model of indoctrination I can think of is to keep a person hostage, isolated from the larger society, expose him/her only to party-approved ideas, carefully select and screen everything he/she reads, every television or other media message he/she receives, and threaten him/her with punishment or excommunication if he/she dares to consider an opposing or divergent viewpoint and fail to spout the party line.)
—Sorry if I offend, but if the shoe fits…
Anyway, back to point the Third: as education has always been the right and responsibility of the States (as opposed to the Federal Government, except in cases in which the state has failed to protect an individual’s right to an education…), and as most of the states allow for local control of public schools, it was made clear well in advance that every district, every school, even every individual teacher was free to choose whether or not to air the address. No one was required to show it. No one was required to watch it. Absolutely no penalties were threatened or imposed on anyone who chose to do a Seek-and-Find or a Sudoku instead. So, claims of “Socialism”—when they really mean “tyranny” or “totalitarianism” anyway—simply don’t hold up. Not when you can legally opt out, without penalty.
Finally, I have heard so many parents—and even some teachers—express “concern” about the “lesson plans” that were offered online by the U.S. Department of Education.
*gasp!*
These “lesson plans” included such indoctrinary and subversive activities as (and these are direct quotations from the DOE website:
http://www.ed.gov/teachers/how/lessons/prek-6.pdf and http://www.ed.gov/teachers/how/lessons/7-12.pdf ):
Having students discuss before the speech:
• Who is the President of the United States?
• To whom do you think the president is going to be speaking?
• Why do you think he wants to speak to you?
• What do you think he will say to you?
OMG! Before even listening to the speech, these indoctrinators want our students to consider the speaker, the audience, the supposed purpose of the speech, and the predicted content… (But, wait, doesn’t that sound like the “motivational activities” from any reading or listening lesson in any textbook from any of the big textbook companies?)
After the speech, it was suggested that:
“Teachers could ask students to share the ideas they recorded…”
(Holy Cow! First they were asked to take notes during the speech and now to share their ideas with other students…?)
“… to discuss main ideas from the speech, such as citizenship, personal responsibility, and civic duty.”
(So are we in favor of these things or opposed to them? I get so confused…! If we’re opposed to modeling good citizenship and teaching civic responsibility to our kids, we should probably stop having school governments, mock elections, Boys and Girls States, American Legion essay contests, etc. After all, we don’t want our kids “indoctrinated” with dangerous ideas…)
One of the final discussion questions in the K-6 guide is,
“What would you like to tell the president?”
Can any whiner or detractor please tell me what model of totalitarian tyranny (which the whiners and detractors still mistakenly call “socialism”) allows young children to respond to a message from the regime-leader?
And if we’re really worried about indoctrination through “free” lesson plans, consider the volume of “educational” materials put out by Coke and Pepsi and sporting goods companies, banks and insurance companies, etc., etc., etc. Consider the coloring books, works sheets, crossword puzzles, story pamphlets “made available” by groups like the NRA, the ALA, the NCTE and IRA, not to mention the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines (and all of their respective ROTCs), all of which have “agendas” they wish to advance through their “free” materials. And don’t forget that private and commercial enterprises are not in any way accountable to the voter and taxpayer the way a government agency like the Department of Education is!
In sum, it seems that we have whiners and complainers whining and complaining about the facts that:
• an elected representative of the People spoke to a portion of those people;
• some of those people apparently do not understand the difference between personal concerns and public concerns, and they do not understand what it means to elect a “representative”;
• some of these same people do not have sufficient vocabulary to frame and articulate their vague concerns in a way that others might understand;
• they do not understand that actions they consider potentially dangerous to their children are already being performed and have been performed for decades by entities far more insidious and far less accountable than an elected representative of the people.
It kind of makes me shake my head in sorrow. I don’t care whether you like the current president or not. I don’t care whether you didn’t vote for him to begin with, or whether you did vote for him and are now disillusioned. I don’t care whether you have kids in public school, private school, or home school. I don’t care whether your kids are adults and already out of school. I don’t care whether your kids are toddlers and not yet in school. I don’t care whether you live in a “red” state or a “blue” state or a state of confusion. I don’t care what your race is, or your gender, or your ethnic heritage, or your religious affiliation, or your income, or your height or weight or hair and eye color. I don’t care whether you’re right- or left-handed, have warts on your toes, or wear eyeglasses. None of these things is an excuse for being stupid.
And I do care if you’re stupid. I do care if you throw around words without knowing what they mean. I do care if you criticize the “other” without knowing what that “other” is.
I do care when you intentionally misrepresent that “other” in order to criticize it (see Exodus 20: 16 and Deuteronomy 5: 20—something about “bear[ing] false witness...”).
I do care if you’re too lazy to verify someone else’s criticism of something you don’t understand yourself (talk about indoctrination!).
And I do care if you create and support a double standard in which X can do something but Y cannot.
And, for all the hubbub, what did President Obama tell the kids? What was his great, socialist agenda?
…Work hard in school because you’ll need your education later on.
How dare he!
So, America, you’re a good idea. But Americans, you need to grow up!
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Everyone Luvs Parody!
Okay, this is my last Ayn Rand post for a while, but I found this today, and it's too funny!
Monday, July 27, 2009
Bad Movie! Bad, Bad Movie!
I really hate it when people don't practice what they preach.
Okay, before I become a preaching hypocrite myself, let me admit that I know we’re all only human, and to hold fast to an ideal is very, very, very difficult (if not outright impossible) in our daily attempts to do as much good as possible and cause as little harm as possible.
But I do hate when highly successful people turn out to have succeeded only at the sacrifice of their...shall I say it?...integrity. You know the kind of person I mean, the Governor who preaches that abstinence is the best and only birth control method (and the only thing teenagers ever need to know about sex), while her own teenaged daughter is … [sigh]; or the Great Religious Leader who rises to national prominence condemning homosexuality while making regular visits to his favorite male prostitute … [sigh]; or the “family values” governor who publicly proclaims that his “soul mate” is a woman in South America, but he will settle for his wife because… [sigh].
And the writer/philosopher who espouses the Great Philosophy of Unyielding Individuality, whose characters say things like, “I don’t build for my clients, I get clients so I can build,” whose climactic moment involves the Unyielding Individualist’s dynamiting a building he’s designed rather than see it bastardized by committee, but sells out her own ideals for a Hollywood contract … [sigh].
I can appreciate the sentiment. There is something lofty and noble about the person who is able to say, “Public be damned, I’m going to do this the way I think it needs to be done.”
Ayn Rand tries to instill this value in her characters. Too bad she doesn't seem able to demonstrate it in her own career.
The Fountainhead, the book, is a two-star attempt at a weakly-plotted philosophical treatise with even weaker characters.
The Fountainhead, the movie, at best exacerbates the flaws of the book and, at worst, enters into a whole new realm of defect. Most movie adaptations of novels—especially adaptations of long novels—are, of necessity, condensations and distillations of the novel on which they are based. Characters are combined, some characters are omitted, plot events are cut short or cut out, time is condensed. Such changes come with the territory, and no one can seriously condemn a movie because it wasn’t absolutely identical to the book on which it was based. (Though we are allowed to admit that “the book was better.”)
In the case of The Fountainhead, however, these condensations and distillations render the movie almost incomprehensible if you haven’t read the book first. The characters in the novel have little enough motivation for their behaviors. In the movie, they have none. A perfect case in point is the character of Ellsworth Toohey, the villain. Rand provides some backstory on Toohey in the novel, and what we learn of his growing up is ostensibly supposed to help us understand the man he becomes. Rand also provides at least a synopsis of the man's rise to power in the novel. He might never quite transcend the stereotype or the cliché, but there is at least an attempt at development. Due to time constraints, however, the Toohey in the film is simply there, arriving in the narrative like Adam in the Garden of Eden—all grown up with no history beyond the day before yesterday. In the novel, when he asks Howard Roark, “What do you think of me?” Roark’s reply has some bite to it because the reader knows that Toohey has been a force behind Roark’s frustrations for a number of years—and Roark knows it too. When Toohey asks the same question in the film, however, the only real reply Roark (and the audience) can offer is, “Who are you, and what is the purpose of this scene?”
Character relationships (vague and unconvincing in the novel) are completely unexplained and unexplored in the film. “You’re engaged to Dominique Francon, aren’t you?” the Powerful Newspaper Mogul asks the Talentless, Spineless Success-story. Someone who’s read the book knows the desired impact of this line, but someone coming fresh to the movie has no idea who Dominique Francon is.
A reader of the novel will also recognize the enormous change from novel to film implicit in this exchange, and this change is a symptom of my strongest criticism of this film.
The novel was released in 1943, the film in 1949. In my earlier post, I described several of the elements of the plot and the characters that were obviously intended to be shocking, things that clearly ran counter to typical 1943-American values: premarital sex, violent sex, adultery, divorce, remarriage, and so on.
One has to admire the challenges Rand must have faced getting her book published and marketed without succumbing to the pressures of censors and public opinion. We know she would not give in because her characters do not give in, and this is what we are supposed to admire about them. This is her Philosophical Message.
There’s even an episode in both the novel and film in which the destitute Roark sacrifices a lucrative contract and refuses to allow one of his buildings to be built rather than accept the modifications to his plan demanded by the clients. And the climactic event in both the book and the movie [spoiler alert: skip to the next paragraph if you really think you’ll read the book or watch the movie and want to be “surprised,”] is Roark’s destruction of a housing development he designed because the design had been altered, and all that he’d demanded was that the project be built exactly as he designed it. His famous speech—which ultimately earns him an acquittal—is all about individual integrity and the danger of compromise.
In Rand’s universe, compromise is bad. Individual integrity is good. One must not yield to public values or tastes, even if that refusal to yield means one will live in obscure poverty. Better to sit alone on a pumpkin than be crowded on a velvet cushion (okay, that’s Thoreau, not Rand, but the philosophies are similar).
Why then, in the translation of book to film, does Rand allow the prevailing values of her day to dictate that she tone down much of what was intended to be shocking in the novel? (And, lest you worry that the novel was adulterated without Rand’s knowledge or consent, be aware that Rand is credited as having written the screenplay herself).
So…when translating book to film, the Unyielding Individualist eliminates all references to divorce. D.F. is not married to P.K., they are “engaged.” She does not embark on a months-long cruise as G.W.’s mistress and then travel to Nevada to divorce P.K. so she can marry G.W. She merely breaks off her engagement. (No adultery, no divorce, no remarriage, no scandal.)
Later, there is no hint of an adulterous affair between D.F. and H.R. And, when they are finally married in the end, she is, again, not divorced but widowed, G.W. having shot himself. (I guess suicide was less shocking to the public sentiment than divorce.)
Of course, without H.R.’s betrayal of G.W., W.’s insistence that R. still build the W-Building loses much of its irony…but, whatever…
So, if it was important in the novel for P.K. and D.F. to be married (to illustrate P.K.’s spinelessness); if it was important for G.W. to essentially buy D.F. from her husband, turn her into his mistress, manipulate her to marry him, etc. (to illustrate his ruthless power and to further emphasize P.K.’s spinelessness), why wasn’t it important to portray these elements in the film?
If we’re supposed to accept Howard Roark’s walking away from a lucrative deal rather than compromise his integrity, if we’re supposed to admire his destroying a building rather than see it bastardized, if we’re supposed to agree that it would be better for the building not to be built than to be built by consensus, then we have to wonder why it was acceptable for Rand to compromise her ideals, to alter aspects of her novel—to “tone them down”—so as not to offend public sensibility.
Wouldn’t it have been better for the movie never to have been made than have its integrity compromised?
Or, conversely, if those elements weren’t crucial to plot and character development, why were they included in the novel? For the sake of sensationalism and titillation?
Looking at the novel and the film, it is difficult to judge whether Ayn Rand is modeling herself after Peter Keating or Gail Wynand; but it is patently clear that she is not Howard Roark.
Okay, before I become a preaching hypocrite myself, let me admit that I know we’re all only human, and to hold fast to an ideal is very, very, very difficult (if not outright impossible) in our daily attempts to do as much good as possible and cause as little harm as possible.
But I do hate when highly successful people turn out to have succeeded only at the sacrifice of their...shall I say it?...integrity. You know the kind of person I mean, the Governor who preaches that abstinence is the best and only birth control method (and the only thing teenagers ever need to know about sex), while her own teenaged daughter is … [sigh]; or the Great Religious Leader who rises to national prominence condemning homosexuality while making regular visits to his favorite male prostitute … [sigh]; or the “family values” governor who publicly proclaims that his “soul mate” is a woman in South America, but he will settle for his wife because… [sigh].
And the writer/philosopher who espouses the Great Philosophy of Unyielding Individuality, whose characters say things like, “I don’t build for my clients, I get clients so I can build,” whose climactic moment involves the Unyielding Individualist’s dynamiting a building he’s designed rather than see it bastardized by committee, but sells out her own ideals for a Hollywood contract … [sigh].
I can appreciate the sentiment. There is something lofty and noble about the person who is able to say, “Public be damned, I’m going to do this the way I think it needs to be done.”
Ayn Rand tries to instill this value in her characters. Too bad she doesn't seem able to demonstrate it in her own career.
The Fountainhead, the book, is a two-star attempt at a weakly-plotted philosophical treatise with even weaker characters.
The Fountainhead, the movie, at best exacerbates the flaws of the book and, at worst, enters into a whole new realm of defect. Most movie adaptations of novels—especially adaptations of long novels—are, of necessity, condensations and distillations of the novel on which they are based. Characters are combined, some characters are omitted, plot events are cut short or cut out, time is condensed. Such changes come with the territory, and no one can seriously condemn a movie because it wasn’t absolutely identical to the book on which it was based. (Though we are allowed to admit that “the book was better.”)
In the case of The Fountainhead, however, these condensations and distillations render the movie almost incomprehensible if you haven’t read the book first. The characters in the novel have little enough motivation for their behaviors. In the movie, they have none. A perfect case in point is the character of Ellsworth Toohey, the villain. Rand provides some backstory on Toohey in the novel, and what we learn of his growing up is ostensibly supposed to help us understand the man he becomes. Rand also provides at least a synopsis of the man's rise to power in the novel. He might never quite transcend the stereotype or the cliché, but there is at least an attempt at development. Due to time constraints, however, the Toohey in the film is simply there, arriving in the narrative like Adam in the Garden of Eden—all grown up with no history beyond the day before yesterday. In the novel, when he asks Howard Roark, “What do you think of me?” Roark’s reply has some bite to it because the reader knows that Toohey has been a force behind Roark’s frustrations for a number of years—and Roark knows it too. When Toohey asks the same question in the film, however, the only real reply Roark (and the audience) can offer is, “Who are you, and what is the purpose of this scene?”
Character relationships (vague and unconvincing in the novel) are completely unexplained and unexplored in the film. “You’re engaged to Dominique Francon, aren’t you?” the Powerful Newspaper Mogul asks the Talentless, Spineless Success-story. Someone who’s read the book knows the desired impact of this line, but someone coming fresh to the movie has no idea who Dominique Francon is.
A reader of the novel will also recognize the enormous change from novel to film implicit in this exchange, and this change is a symptom of my strongest criticism of this film.
The novel was released in 1943, the film in 1949. In my earlier post, I described several of the elements of the plot and the characters that were obviously intended to be shocking, things that clearly ran counter to typical 1943-American values: premarital sex, violent sex, adultery, divorce, remarriage, and so on.
One has to admire the challenges Rand must have faced getting her book published and marketed without succumbing to the pressures of censors and public opinion. We know she would not give in because her characters do not give in, and this is what we are supposed to admire about them. This is her Philosophical Message.
There’s even an episode in both the novel and film in which the destitute Roark sacrifices a lucrative contract and refuses to allow one of his buildings to be built rather than accept the modifications to his plan demanded by the clients. And the climactic event in both the book and the movie [spoiler alert: skip to the next paragraph if you really think you’ll read the book or watch the movie and want to be “surprised,”] is Roark’s destruction of a housing development he designed because the design had been altered, and all that he’d demanded was that the project be built exactly as he designed it. His famous speech—which ultimately earns him an acquittal—is all about individual integrity and the danger of compromise.
In Rand’s universe, compromise is bad. Individual integrity is good. One must not yield to public values or tastes, even if that refusal to yield means one will live in obscure poverty. Better to sit alone on a pumpkin than be crowded on a velvet cushion (okay, that’s Thoreau, not Rand, but the philosophies are similar).
Why then, in the translation of book to film, does Rand allow the prevailing values of her day to dictate that she tone down much of what was intended to be shocking in the novel? (And, lest you worry that the novel was adulterated without Rand’s knowledge or consent, be aware that Rand is credited as having written the screenplay herself).
So…when translating book to film, the Unyielding Individualist eliminates all references to divorce. D.F. is not married to P.K., they are “engaged.” She does not embark on a months-long cruise as G.W.’s mistress and then travel to Nevada to divorce P.K. so she can marry G.W. She merely breaks off her engagement. (No adultery, no divorce, no remarriage, no scandal.)
Later, there is no hint of an adulterous affair between D.F. and H.R. And, when they are finally married in the end, she is, again, not divorced but widowed, G.W. having shot himself. (I guess suicide was less shocking to the public sentiment than divorce.)
Of course, without H.R.’s betrayal of G.W., W.’s insistence that R. still build the W-Building loses much of its irony…but, whatever…
So, if it was important in the novel for P.K. and D.F. to be married (to illustrate P.K.’s spinelessness); if it was important for G.W. to essentially buy D.F. from her husband, turn her into his mistress, manipulate her to marry him, etc. (to illustrate his ruthless power and to further emphasize P.K.’s spinelessness), why wasn’t it important to portray these elements in the film?
If we’re supposed to accept Howard Roark’s walking away from a lucrative deal rather than compromise his integrity, if we’re supposed to admire his destroying a building rather than see it bastardized, if we’re supposed to agree that it would be better for the building not to be built than to be built by consensus, then we have to wonder why it was acceptable for Rand to compromise her ideals, to alter aspects of her novel—to “tone them down”—so as not to offend public sensibility.
Wouldn’t it have been better for the movie never to have been made than have its integrity compromised?
Or, conversely, if those elements weren’t crucial to plot and character development, why were they included in the novel? For the sake of sensationalism and titillation?
Looking at the novel and the film, it is difficult to judge whether Ayn Rand is modeling herself after Peter Keating or Gail Wynand; but it is patently clear that she is not Howard Roark.
Friday, July 24, 2009
Pretty Much a Dumb Book...
So a few weeks ago, I finally finished reading The Fountainhead. I’d been reading it since, like, April. It was one of those books that, while I was reading it, I was curious enough to find out what was going to happen next; but, once I put the bookmark in and set it down, I was not overly compelled to pick it up again. (That’s pretty much why it took me three months to read the thing.)
Imitating Amazon.com’s five-star reader-rater system, I think I’d have to give this book two stars. (I know, it’s one of those classics, kind of like War and Peace, that carry their own aura of…Oh, you’re reading The Fountainhead! or Wow, you’ve actually read The Fountainhead!)
But I still give it only two stars.
Here’s why:
The plot’s kind of dumb. It’s one of those spanning-years-in-the-lives-of-the-characters books that I usually enjoy, but too much of the plot is predictable. You know that the one guy is going to have a meteoric rise to fame and fortune (and you know he’s going to fall out of favor just as quickly). You know the other guy (the main character) is going to live a miserable, frustrated life. You know that, as soon as the one guy starts to become BFFs with the guy who used to be his enemy that he’s going to betray this new BFF.
You know the one guy is going to get the girl!
Even worse, though, the parts of the plot that weren’t thoroughly predictable were ridiculous in their blatant attempts at being shocking. Now, I’m not opposed to shocking, and good literature should push the envelope, but most of the ostensibly scandalizing elements in The Fountainhead were absolutely without context or motivation—more on that in a minute.
And much of what was intended to be shocking—rough sex, violence, divorce and remarriage—has lost its “punch” since the book was first released in 1943. (I’ve got the DVD starring Gary Cooper and Patricia Neal coming from Netflix, so I’m curious to see how a forties-era movie producer portrayed these elements.) So, what was provocative to my parents is now just silly—especially silly when you know it’s supposed to be outrageous.
In addition to a dumb plot, the novel is populated with dumb characters. Again, Rand is obviously trying to craft new and surprising characters, but in her attempts, she actually creates a whole new stereotype—and all of her characters adhere quite strictly to that stereotype. These are characters who are absolutely unyielding in their intent not to act in their own best interest. Whether the character is a cop-out (like the one who rises meteorically to fame and fortune and gets the girl—at least for a while) or a strong-willed individualist (like the guy who lives the miserable life but gets the girl in the end), none of these characters is motivated by anything real. (Some of them don’t seem to be motivated by anything at all!) Perhaps Rand is trying to create archetypes, but archetypes of what? No one achieves any kind of happiness because no one acts in a way that would foster any kind of happiness.
Perhaps the main character comes the closest because we’re supposed to believe that he doesn’t care. But, then, if he doesn’t care, why should I?
Even “the girl” acts completely without motive—unless her motive is to behave in ways that Rand’s readers will find “shocking.” Ultimately, you don’t really care what happens to any of these characters because none of them has any real emotional or psychological depth.
So, you’ve essentially got a bunch of vapid characters performing a lot of predictably-shocking actions and spouting some philosophy—not exactly a five-star literary experience.
Now, here’s what I did like about the book. Rand’s writing style is really quite beautiful. While most of her images are, again, clichéd—the beautiful, slender woman, leaning against the rail of a yacht, her white dress, fluttering in the tropical breeze; the powerful man, standing like a colossus before a window, the nighttime skyline of New York sparkling behind him—she describes them vividly and beautifully. And, to be fair, perhaps these images weren’t clichés when she devised them in 1943. Again, I’m anxious to see the movie if only to see how director King Vidor translates these images onto the screen.
Maybe I’d be more forgiving of the novel’s shortcomings if it weren’t so heralded as a Great Book—there’s even this huge essay contest with a $10,000 First Prize for high school students. Still, that’s a testimony to the effectiveness of the Ayn Rand institute and nothing else. But, as for originality of plot, effectiveness of things like suspense, irony, etc.; for credible, sympathetic characters; for exploration of ideas, I’m still sticking with my two-star rating.
I did like Anthem, though. Maybe one of these days I’ll tackle Atlas Shrugged.
Imitating Amazon.com’s five-star reader-rater system, I think I’d have to give this book two stars. (I know, it’s one of those classics, kind of like War and Peace, that carry their own aura of…Oh, you’re reading The Fountainhead! or Wow, you’ve actually read The Fountainhead!)
But I still give it only two stars.
Here’s why:
The plot’s kind of dumb. It’s one of those spanning-years-in-the-lives-of-the-characters books that I usually enjoy, but too much of the plot is predictable. You know that the one guy is going to have a meteoric rise to fame and fortune (and you know he’s going to fall out of favor just as quickly). You know the other guy (the main character) is going to live a miserable, frustrated life. You know that, as soon as the one guy starts to become BFFs with the guy who used to be his enemy that he’s going to betray this new BFF.
You know the one guy is going to get the girl!
Even worse, though, the parts of the plot that weren’t thoroughly predictable were ridiculous in their blatant attempts at being shocking. Now, I’m not opposed to shocking, and good literature should push the envelope, but most of the ostensibly scandalizing elements in The Fountainhead were absolutely without context or motivation—more on that in a minute.
And much of what was intended to be shocking—rough sex, violence, divorce and remarriage—has lost its “punch” since the book was first released in 1943. (I’ve got the DVD starring Gary Cooper and Patricia Neal coming from Netflix, so I’m curious to see how a forties-era movie producer portrayed these elements.) So, what was provocative to my parents is now just silly—especially silly when you know it’s supposed to be outrageous.
In addition to a dumb plot, the novel is populated with dumb characters. Again, Rand is obviously trying to craft new and surprising characters, but in her attempts, she actually creates a whole new stereotype—and all of her characters adhere quite strictly to that stereotype. These are characters who are absolutely unyielding in their intent not to act in their own best interest. Whether the character is a cop-out (like the one who rises meteorically to fame and fortune and gets the girl—at least for a while) or a strong-willed individualist (like the guy who lives the miserable life but gets the girl in the end), none of these characters is motivated by anything real. (Some of them don’t seem to be motivated by anything at all!) Perhaps Rand is trying to create archetypes, but archetypes of what? No one achieves any kind of happiness because no one acts in a way that would foster any kind of happiness.
Perhaps the main character comes the closest because we’re supposed to believe that he doesn’t care. But, then, if he doesn’t care, why should I?
Even “the girl” acts completely without motive—unless her motive is to behave in ways that Rand’s readers will find “shocking.” Ultimately, you don’t really care what happens to any of these characters because none of them has any real emotional or psychological depth.
So, you’ve essentially got a bunch of vapid characters performing a lot of predictably-shocking actions and spouting some philosophy—not exactly a five-star literary experience.
Now, here’s what I did like about the book. Rand’s writing style is really quite beautiful. While most of her images are, again, clichéd—the beautiful, slender woman, leaning against the rail of a yacht, her white dress, fluttering in the tropical breeze; the powerful man, standing like a colossus before a window, the nighttime skyline of New York sparkling behind him—she describes them vividly and beautifully. And, to be fair, perhaps these images weren’t clichés when she devised them in 1943. Again, I’m anxious to see the movie if only to see how director King Vidor translates these images onto the screen.
Maybe I’d be more forgiving of the novel’s shortcomings if it weren’t so heralded as a Great Book—there’s even this huge essay contest with a $10,000 First Prize for high school students. Still, that’s a testimony to the effectiveness of the Ayn Rand institute and nothing else. But, as for originality of plot, effectiveness of things like suspense, irony, etc.; for credible, sympathetic characters; for exploration of ideas, I’m still sticking with my two-star rating.
I did like Anthem, though. Maybe one of these days I’ll tackle Atlas Shrugged.
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Here's a Joke for You All
A literary agent walks into a doctor’s office and begins describing the most horrendous symptoms when, all of a sudden, the doctor—who’s never looked up from the agent’s chart—interrupts the agent and says, “I’m sorry, but unfortunately, I am not enthusiastic enough about your case to offer you medical care. Best regards for your future, and thank you for allowing me to review your case.”
Thursday, July 2, 2009
With Liberty and Justice for…Whom, Exactly?
What’s up with the Supreme Court these days? Have they simply tossed the concepts of law and justice aside?
I’m not overly concerned with this week’s ruling overturning that decision about the New Haven, CT, firefighters in which Judge Sotomayor participated (as I understand it, she was not the only judge on the case, so the decision was not hers alone). After all, if I’d taken a test to qualify for a promotion and pay raise, passed it, and then was denied the promotion and raise because someone else had failed the test (race and gender aside), I’d be pretty upset.
Gimme the raise I qualified for and fix the test!
Still, the decision does essentially rewrite about forty years of legislative action and legal precedent.
And it’s hard to believe that the 5 – 4 decision was anything but purely political. I mean, come on, who’s trying to discredit whose nomination to the Supreme Court? Sheesh!
And, okay, they did find that that Arizona school district did violate that girl’s rights when they stripped her down to her panties (and then looked inside) to see if she was hiding, like, three ibuprofen tablets.
But I am appalled by their earlier decision, the one where they said that convicts do not have a Constitutional right to have their own DNA tested if they think the test will exonerate them. A person sitting in prison for a crime he (or she) did not commit (let’s face it, how many prisoners would request a DNA test that would prove their guilt?) does not have the right to demand that his (or her) DNA be tested against whatever DNA is in evidence connected with the case even when he (or she) knows that the test will prove his (or her) innocence!!!!!
Here’s a link to one of the many articles about the decision.
Chief Justice Roberts himself wrote (in the decision denying the right to the wrongfully convicted) that DNA testing (as seen on television) has an “unparalleled ability both to exonerate the wrongly convicted and to identify the guilty’’ (emphasis mine). In fact, already some 200+ wrongfully-convicted men (and women) have been so exonerated and released from prison. Even so, we cannot require states to perform to perform the simple test. A convict does not have the right to demand such a test.
It’s better to keep an innocent man (or woman) in prison and to let the truly guilty go free than to…I don’t even know what.
What were those 5 Supreme Court Justices thinking? (Gee, another 5 – 4 split. Same 5? Same 4? Does anyone see a pattern here?)
Anyway, I’ll tell you what those 5 were not thinking; they were not thinking:
“I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me,” (Matthew 25:40 NIV).
They were not thinking:
“Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free,” (John 8: 32 NIV).
Christian principles indeed.
I’m not overly concerned with this week’s ruling overturning that decision about the New Haven, CT, firefighters in which Judge Sotomayor participated (as I understand it, she was not the only judge on the case, so the decision was not hers alone). After all, if I’d taken a test to qualify for a promotion and pay raise, passed it, and then was denied the promotion and raise because someone else had failed the test (race and gender aside), I’d be pretty upset.
Gimme the raise I qualified for and fix the test!
Still, the decision does essentially rewrite about forty years of legislative action and legal precedent.
And it’s hard to believe that the 5 – 4 decision was anything but purely political. I mean, come on, who’s trying to discredit whose nomination to the Supreme Court? Sheesh!
And, okay, they did find that that Arizona school district did violate that girl’s rights when they stripped her down to her panties (and then looked inside) to see if she was hiding, like, three ibuprofen tablets.
But I am appalled by their earlier decision, the one where they said that convicts do not have a Constitutional right to have their own DNA tested if they think the test will exonerate them. A person sitting in prison for a crime he (or she) did not commit (let’s face it, how many prisoners would request a DNA test that would prove their guilt?) does not have the right to demand that his (or her) DNA be tested against whatever DNA is in evidence connected with the case even when he (or she) knows that the test will prove his (or her) innocence!!!!!
Here’s a link to one of the many articles about the decision.
Chief Justice Roberts himself wrote (in the decision denying the right to the wrongfully convicted) that DNA testing (as seen on television) has an “unparalleled ability both to exonerate the wrongly convicted and to identify the guilty’’ (emphasis mine). In fact, already some 200+ wrongfully-convicted men (and women) have been so exonerated and released from prison. Even so, we cannot require states to perform to perform the simple test. A convict does not have the right to demand such a test.
It’s better to keep an innocent man (or woman) in prison and to let the truly guilty go free than to…I don’t even know what.
What were those 5 Supreme Court Justices thinking? (Gee, another 5 – 4 split. Same 5? Same 4? Does anyone see a pattern here?)
Anyway, I’ll tell you what those 5 were not thinking; they were not thinking:
“I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me,” (Matthew 25:40 NIV).
They were not thinking:
“Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free,” (John 8: 32 NIV).
Christian principles indeed.
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
2, 4, 6, 8, Who We Gonna IMITATE?
Okay, so J. D. Salinger, 90 and in poor health, is suing a California-based writer for writing a book whose main character is a 76-year-old Holden Caulfield.
Here's the link to the article I read in the New York Times this morning.
I understand the J.K Rowling thing; the kid who wrote the "guidebook" didn't really contribute anything to the conversation. He just arranged and indexed material Rowling had created.
The Wind Done Gone was, like, a totally different book.
Most recently, there's a novelist making a fortune "borrowing" characters and situations from other writers' works (most famously L. Frank Baum) and recasting them, telling the characters' stories from other viewpoints—you did know that that was what Wicked is all about, right?
I've also read an odd, but not awful, novel—a mystery—whose protagonist is an all-grown-up "Tiny Tim" Cratchit from A Christmas Carol fame. Ebenezer Scrooge puts in a few appearances as well.
Years ago I read Mrs. de Winter, the really, really awful "sequel" to Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca.
Indeed, this whole recasting of other stories, continuing the lives of characters already-made famous, seems to be an industry standard. It almost seems as if you can't get a book published unless it's a rehash of "same-old, same-old."
So we all understand that Salinger is a tad eccentric, and he admirably loves his works and his characters, but I don't see the big deal.
Here's the link to the article I read in the New York Times this morning.
I understand the J.K Rowling thing; the kid who wrote the "guidebook" didn't really contribute anything to the conversation. He just arranged and indexed material Rowling had created.
The Wind Done Gone was, like, a totally different book.
Most recently, there's a novelist making a fortune "borrowing" characters and situations from other writers' works (most famously L. Frank Baum) and recasting them, telling the characters' stories from other viewpoints—you did know that that was what Wicked is all about, right?
I've also read an odd, but not awful, novel—a mystery—whose protagonist is an all-grown-up "Tiny Tim" Cratchit from A Christmas Carol fame. Ebenezer Scrooge puts in a few appearances as well.
Years ago I read Mrs. de Winter, the really, really awful "sequel" to Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca.
Indeed, this whole recasting of other stories, continuing the lives of characters already-made famous, seems to be an industry standard. It almost seems as if you can't get a book published unless it's a rehash of "same-old, same-old."
So we all understand that Salinger is a tad eccentric, and he admirably loves his works and his characters, but I don't see the big deal.
Monday, June 15, 2009
God Bless America? (2)
So, about those ubiquitous God Bless America signs, banners, etc. It occurs to me that maybe God is...blessing America, that is. The irony is that many (or most) of the same people who wave their flags and smear red-white-and-blue bumper stickers all over their cars don’t even realize it.
It’s a common theme in the Old and New Testaments—culminating in the Gospel of John— people’s prayers being answered and their not knowing it. (“The Word was in the world ... but the world did not know him.”John 1:10.).
Here’s what I think might be going on:
We have an elected President—elected by a wide-enough margin of both the popular and electoral votes that the legality of his election is not in question—who can make a speech in a foreign country (one that does not love the United States and is ideologically allied with other countries who outright hate us) and receives applause and cheers.
In this speech, he says to our would-be enemies that it would be more powerful to love one another than to try to destroy one another. He says to our friends that, while they are yet our friends, he expects them to act with justice and…yes…love toward their enemies. (I think there’s something in the New Testament about loving our enemies and blessing those who persecute us.)
We have an elected President who has demonstrated the wisdom and (dare I say it…) the “Christian” values of love and forgiveness to the extent that he has appointed one of his most bitter political rivals to one of the most influential positions in his administration. He has filled his cabinet with both supporters and representatives of his detractors.
He is willing to listen to those who disagree with him. He is willing to speak with those with whom he disagrees.
I keep hearing that we are a “Christian nation,” founded upon “Christian principles.” Having actually read our founding documents—the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Articles of Confederation (which were replaced by the Constitution, but are still among our “founding documents”), and the first ten amendments to the Constitution (collectively known as the Bill of Rights)— the only specific reference to religion I can find is in the First Amendment where it says the government isn’t going to support or denigrate any particular religion. I don’t find a single reference to Jesus, or the Crucifixion, or the Resurrection—any of those things that are uniquely Christian.
Still, having also read the New Testament (paying special attention to the Gospels, you know, those things that Jesus told his disciples to do), I have to say, I am seeing “Christian principles” actually put into practice nearly every time our current President speaks or acts. I think there’s something in the Gospels about being “known by [our] fruit,” that a good tree can’t help but produce “good fruit,” and a bad tree can’t help but produce “bad fruit.”
Well, we’ve glutted ourselves on the “fruit” of the previous administration, and now we have a new President who’s planting a new orchard.
Someone inclined to speak in such terms might be tempted to conclude that God is blessing America…
Oddly, however, the very people who display their God Bless America bumper stickers are the ones who seem to be missing the point—at least if you listen to their unelected (but ever popular) spokespersons, that’s what it seems.
Not to equate President Obama with J.C. himself, but it strikes me as wildly ironic that, “[he] was in the world… but the world did not know him.”
I guess the God Bless America-ers were hoping for the complete annihilation of our enemies and total world domination. Christian principles indeed.
It’s a common theme in the Old and New Testaments—culminating in the Gospel of John— people’s prayers being answered and their not knowing it. (“The Word was in the world ... but the world did not know him.”John 1:10.).
Here’s what I think might be going on:
We have an elected President—elected by a wide-enough margin of both the popular and electoral votes that the legality of his election is not in question—who can make a speech in a foreign country (one that does not love the United States and is ideologically allied with other countries who outright hate us) and receives applause and cheers.
In this speech, he says to our would-be enemies that it would be more powerful to love one another than to try to destroy one another. He says to our friends that, while they are yet our friends, he expects them to act with justice and…yes…love toward their enemies. (I think there’s something in the New Testament about loving our enemies and blessing those who persecute us.)
We have an elected President who has demonstrated the wisdom and (dare I say it…) the “Christian” values of love and forgiveness to the extent that he has appointed one of his most bitter political rivals to one of the most influential positions in his administration. He has filled his cabinet with both supporters and representatives of his detractors.
He is willing to listen to those who disagree with him. He is willing to speak with those with whom he disagrees.
I keep hearing that we are a “Christian nation,” founded upon “Christian principles.” Having actually read our founding documents—the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Articles of Confederation (which were replaced by the Constitution, but are still among our “founding documents”), and the first ten amendments to the Constitution (collectively known as the Bill of Rights)— the only specific reference to religion I can find is in the First Amendment where it says the government isn’t going to support or denigrate any particular religion. I don’t find a single reference to Jesus, or the Crucifixion, or the Resurrection—any of those things that are uniquely Christian.
Still, having also read the New Testament (paying special attention to the Gospels, you know, those things that Jesus told his disciples to do), I have to say, I am seeing “Christian principles” actually put into practice nearly every time our current President speaks or acts. I think there’s something in the Gospels about being “known by [our] fruit,” that a good tree can’t help but produce “good fruit,” and a bad tree can’t help but produce “bad fruit.”
Well, we’ve glutted ourselves on the “fruit” of the previous administration, and now we have a new President who’s planting a new orchard.
Someone inclined to speak in such terms might be tempted to conclude that God is blessing America…
Oddly, however, the very people who display their God Bless America bumper stickers are the ones who seem to be missing the point—at least if you listen to their unelected (but ever popular) spokespersons, that’s what it seems.
Not to equate President Obama with J.C. himself, but it strikes me as wildly ironic that, “[he] was in the world… but the world did not know him.”
I guess the God Bless America-ers were hoping for the complete annihilation of our enemies and total world domination. Christian principles indeed.
Thursday, June 11, 2009
God Bless America? (1)
Lately I’ve been thinking about all those “God Bless America” signs, posters, notices, bumper stickers, yada yada yada, that have become ubiquitous since, probably, the first Gulf War a kajillion years ago.
These notices kind of offend me—not because I an un- or anti-American, but because I do not believe that God is much of a nationalist. It makes me think of three widely different allusions:
The first is a sarcastic little exchange from the 1970s musical Pippin. The titular character (I just wanted to use that word because it sounds so risqué) is praying with his father, Charlemagne, on the eve of a great battle. Of course, they’re praying for victory in the battle. Pippin asks his father whether the king of the opposing army is also praying for victory. Charlemagne responds that, of course, he is, and he is “one of the best pray-ers in the business.” The point is fairly clear: both sides cannot win the battle, but both enter the battle believing that God is on their side.
See the irony?
The second is more serious. In his second inaugural address, toward the end of the Civil War and little more than a month before he would be assassinated, Abraham Lincoln says of both the North and the South:
“Both read the same Bible and pray to the same God, and each invokes His aid against the other. … The prayers of both could not be answered. … [but] … The Almighty has His own purposes.”
Lincoln, of course, is committed to the cause of the North: the preservation of the United States of America and the end of slavery. Still, he acknowledges his own mortal imperfection in presuming to know Divine will and intent:
“With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in …”
See what Lincoln is suggesting to his fellow Americans? Perhaps, an essential part of praying for the success of our cause is to pray to be shown what the right cause is…!
Okay, one more cool reference, and then I’ll get to my point.
There’s a song I first learned in elementary school (and, therefore, never really appreciated until recently) and then used to sing quite frequently in church. I just always called it “Finlandia,” but this apparently refers only to the melody (by Jean Sibelius). The words were written by Lloyd Stone:
This is my song, O God of all the nations,
A song of peace for lands afar and mine.
This is my home, the country where my heart is;
Here are my hopes, my dreams, my holy shrine;
But other hearts in other lands are beating
With hopes and dreams as true and high as mine.
My country's skies are bluer than the ocean,
And sunlight beams on clover-leaf and pine.
But other lands have sunlight too and clover,
And skies are everywhere as blue as mine.
Oh, hear my song, O God of all the nations,
A song of peace for their land and for mine.
I’m sorry if I’ve violated someone’s copyright by reproducing the words here, but several phrases continue to resonate with me, especially when we choose to throw around the words “God,” “bless,” and the name of a country:
“O God of all the nations.”
• Well, duh, but do those with “God Bless America” bumper stickers realize this?
“…other hearts in other lands are beating with hopes and dreams as true and high as mine.”
• But surely not hearts in the lands of our enemies (or, at least, not the hearts of the people we call our enemies)?
“…other lands have sunlight too and clover, and skies are everywhere as blue as mine.”
• So, the “blessings” we ask God to bestow on America are not uniquely ours? Or do we hope they will be?
Okay, here’s my point. If we are a God-fearing nation (as would appear on the surface), then, perhaps we should be a little more aware of the demographics of “God’s Kingdom” and more reverent in invoking His “blessings.” What exactly are those ubiquitous bumper stickers asking for? What exactly do we expect in answer to our petition?
My suspicion is that most of us haven’t bothered to think about it.
But Pippin did. Lincoln did. And Lloyd stone did.
Probably we should too.
These notices kind of offend me—not because I an un- or anti-American, but because I do not believe that God is much of a nationalist. It makes me think of three widely different allusions:
The first is a sarcastic little exchange from the 1970s musical Pippin. The titular character (I just wanted to use that word because it sounds so risqué) is praying with his father, Charlemagne, on the eve of a great battle. Of course, they’re praying for victory in the battle. Pippin asks his father whether the king of the opposing army is also praying for victory. Charlemagne responds that, of course, he is, and he is “one of the best pray-ers in the business.” The point is fairly clear: both sides cannot win the battle, but both enter the battle believing that God is on their side.
See the irony?
The second is more serious. In his second inaugural address, toward the end of the Civil War and little more than a month before he would be assassinated, Abraham Lincoln says of both the North and the South:
“Both read the same Bible and pray to the same God, and each invokes His aid against the other. … The prayers of both could not be answered. … [but] … The Almighty has His own purposes.”
Lincoln, of course, is committed to the cause of the North: the preservation of the United States of America and the end of slavery. Still, he acknowledges his own mortal imperfection in presuming to know Divine will and intent:
“With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in …”
See what Lincoln is suggesting to his fellow Americans? Perhaps, an essential part of praying for the success of our cause is to pray to be shown what the right cause is…!
Okay, one more cool reference, and then I’ll get to my point.
There’s a song I first learned in elementary school (and, therefore, never really appreciated until recently) and then used to sing quite frequently in church. I just always called it “Finlandia,” but this apparently refers only to the melody (by Jean Sibelius). The words were written by Lloyd Stone:
This is my song, O God of all the nations,
A song of peace for lands afar and mine.
This is my home, the country where my heart is;
Here are my hopes, my dreams, my holy shrine;
But other hearts in other lands are beating
With hopes and dreams as true and high as mine.
My country's skies are bluer than the ocean,
And sunlight beams on clover-leaf and pine.
But other lands have sunlight too and clover,
And skies are everywhere as blue as mine.
Oh, hear my song, O God of all the nations,
A song of peace for their land and for mine.
I’m sorry if I’ve violated someone’s copyright by reproducing the words here, but several phrases continue to resonate with me, especially when we choose to throw around the words “God,” “bless,” and the name of a country:
“O God of all the nations.”
• Well, duh, but do those with “God Bless America” bumper stickers realize this?
“…other hearts in other lands are beating with hopes and dreams as true and high as mine.”
• But surely not hearts in the lands of our enemies (or, at least, not the hearts of the people we call our enemies)?
“…other lands have sunlight too and clover, and skies are everywhere as blue as mine.”
• So, the “blessings” we ask God to bestow on America are not uniquely ours? Or do we hope they will be?
Okay, here’s my point. If we are a God-fearing nation (as would appear on the surface), then, perhaps we should be a little more aware of the demographics of “God’s Kingdom” and more reverent in invoking His “blessings.” What exactly are those ubiquitous bumper stickers asking for? What exactly do we expect in answer to our petition?
My suspicion is that most of us haven’t bothered to think about it.
But Pippin did. Lincoln did. And Lloyd stone did.
Probably we should too.
Saturday, May 2, 2009
From Russia, with Love
I grew up in Jersey City, New Jersey (back then, we called it “Jerkey City”). Bayonne was (still is, actually) the next city south. Growing up, I had a few friends who lived in Bayonne, swam occasionally in what we called the “Bayonne Pool,” played in Bayonne Park, and, of course, crossed the Bayonne Bridge to get to Staten Island.
Growing up, I was fascinated to watch the building of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge (which was, at the time, the world’s longest suspension bridge) and the World Trade Center (which was, at the time, the world’s tallest building).
Even after my mother left Jersey City in 1986, my family found the occasional reason to return, eating at the VIP Diner on Sip Avenue and “the Boulevard,” driving through Lincoln Park, and parking at the foot of Montgomery Street to take the New York Waterway boats into...uh...New York.
I like to think I’ve been paying attention. It’s not as if I left the area and never looked back. My kids and I have been to Liberty State Park (and we’ve watched it grow in size and reputation). We’ve ridden the boats from Jersey City to the Statue of Liberty and from Jersey City to Ellis Island.
So how is it that I never heard of the 9/11 memorial entitled To the Struggle Against World Terrorism, which was created by Russian sculptor Zurab Tsereteli and presented as a gift from “the People of Russia”? Apparently former President Bill Clinton attended the September 11, 2006 dedication ceremony. (President Bush did not.)
Here’s the web site with the brochure announcing the dedication.
Here’s the entry at Snopes.com verifying that this memorial does indeed exist. (I checked after I got one of those mass forwards talking about the memorial and wondering why there has never been any mention of this gift from the Russian people or this memorial to one of the darkest days in United States history).
And here’s my whine: Just like the originators of the mass forward I received this afternoon, and the person who contacted Snopes to ask whether this memorial did, in fact, exist, I have to ask why there was no press coverage—or precious little press coverage. As I said, it’s not like I haven’t been paying attention.
We all know how things like this are usually touted in the papers, on television, and on the Internet from the moment the concept is first mentioned—and interested people would be able to follow the project through site selection, construction, completion, and dedication. We all know how the collective press likes to sentimentalize and/or sensationalize every aspect of such a story—highlight survivors who protest, emphasize the claim that some people question the authenticity of some of the names engraved in the memorial, exaggerate and report with righteous indignation whatever bureaucratic hassles may have been involved in the process...
But my daughter went to college on Staten Island from 2002 to 2006 and she never mentioned that she’d heard or read about them building this memorial just a few miles from her campus! Knowing my daughter, if she’d known such a thing was being built, she’d have loaded her car with friends and driven into Bayonne to find it. And when she got lost, she’d have called me to ask for directions. So I would have heard about it if she had heard about it.
So why all the secrecy? Because it was a gift from the Russians? Because it was being built in –gasp- New Jersey?
Both sound like pathetic and petty reasons, but what other reason could there be?
How could the collective press have been so...indifferent to an international gesture of good will? I doubt the American people would have received the news of this gesture so indifferently.
I hope to God not, anyway.
First chance I get this spring or summer, I’m driving up to Bayonne to see it. From the pictures, it looks like a lovely monument.
Too bad nobody knows it’s there!
Growing up, I was fascinated to watch the building of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge (which was, at the time, the world’s longest suspension bridge) and the World Trade Center (which was, at the time, the world’s tallest building).
Even after my mother left Jersey City in 1986, my family found the occasional reason to return, eating at the VIP Diner on Sip Avenue and “the Boulevard,” driving through Lincoln Park, and parking at the foot of Montgomery Street to take the New York Waterway boats into...uh...New York.
I like to think I’ve been paying attention. It’s not as if I left the area and never looked back. My kids and I have been to Liberty State Park (and we’ve watched it grow in size and reputation). We’ve ridden the boats from Jersey City to the Statue of Liberty and from Jersey City to Ellis Island.
So how is it that I never heard of the 9/11 memorial entitled To the Struggle Against World Terrorism, which was created by Russian sculptor Zurab Tsereteli and presented as a gift from “the People of Russia”? Apparently former President Bill Clinton attended the September 11, 2006 dedication ceremony. (President Bush did not.)
Here’s the web site with the brochure announcing the dedication.
Here’s the entry at Snopes.com verifying that this memorial does indeed exist. (I checked after I got one of those mass forwards talking about the memorial and wondering why there has never been any mention of this gift from the Russian people or this memorial to one of the darkest days in United States history).
And here’s my whine: Just like the originators of the mass forward I received this afternoon, and the person who contacted Snopes to ask whether this memorial did, in fact, exist, I have to ask why there was no press coverage—or precious little press coverage. As I said, it’s not like I haven’t been paying attention.
We all know how things like this are usually touted in the papers, on television, and on the Internet from the moment the concept is first mentioned—and interested people would be able to follow the project through site selection, construction, completion, and dedication. We all know how the collective press likes to sentimentalize and/or sensationalize every aspect of such a story—highlight survivors who protest, emphasize the claim that some people question the authenticity of some of the names engraved in the memorial, exaggerate and report with righteous indignation whatever bureaucratic hassles may have been involved in the process...
But my daughter went to college on Staten Island from 2002 to 2006 and she never mentioned that she’d heard or read about them building this memorial just a few miles from her campus! Knowing my daughter, if she’d known such a thing was being built, she’d have loaded her car with friends and driven into Bayonne to find it. And when she got lost, she’d have called me to ask for directions. So I would have heard about it if she had heard about it.
So why all the secrecy? Because it was a gift from the Russians? Because it was being built in –gasp- New Jersey?
Both sound like pathetic and petty reasons, but what other reason could there be?
How could the collective press have been so...indifferent to an international gesture of good will? I doubt the American people would have received the news of this gesture so indifferently.
I hope to God not, anyway.
First chance I get this spring or summer, I’m driving up to Bayonne to see it. From the pictures, it looks like a lovely monument.
Too bad nobody knows it’s there!
Monday, April 27, 2009
Let's Hear It for School Prayer!
I’ve been thinking a lot about school prayer. I think we should have it.
Now, I’m not taking about prayer in school. Because we’ve always had that. There’ve always been the kids who sit at their table in the cafeteria, hold hands, and say some form of grace before eating their peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. There’ve always been the kids who maybe cross themselves (or whatever their ritual or tradition might be), close their eyes, and mouth a little prayer before their final exam.
I don’t know of any who have been burnt at the stake for having a private, little moment of communion with their deity. They might get stared at; some of their less-enlightened classmates might make an ignorant comment to them, but that’s another issue for another day (“10Blessed are they that are persecuted for righteousness’ sake...11Blessed are ye when men shall revile you …” Matthew 5: 10-11).
Personally, I’ve always thought that the people who complained that they “couldn’t pray” at any given time or place probably weren’t very strong pray-ers to begin with.
But I’m talking about mandated school prayer. I think we should have it. I think we should all write and call our state legislators and demand it. Constitution be damned, every kid in every public school should be required to pray at least once a day.
Given the proper legislation, mandatory, organized school prayer—that so many people on Fox News and the Internet seem to want—could be fully instituted in a month or less.
Here’s a model we could follow:
The Islamic faith has five obligated prayer times, one of which—the noon prayer—occurs during the school day, so this is the one we will adopt. Since the First Amendment guarantees all Muslim students the right to the “free exercise” of their religion, since they have a noon-prayer obligation, and since the supporters of school prayer don’t seem to think there’s any harm in forcing kids to participate in prayer rituals foreign to their own, no one should object to a mandatory noon-prayer break. (Okay, granted, there are those liberals who say that kids who “choose not to participate” in the prayer can absent themselves, so we’ll let those who choose not to participate in this mandatory prayer stand in the hallways or something.)
Booklets explaining the appropriate postures and teaching the words and pronunciations can be distributed in English and social studies classes, and the proper attire can be made available from either the school nurse or the guidance department. With diligence and consistency, within a month, the practice of pausing at noon for organized prayer can be well established in every public school from sea to shining sea.
Of course, it just occurred to me that there might be those with…uh…narrow perspectives, who would object to Islamic prayer in school. We won’t go into what their objections might be, let’s just know that there might be objections—this is America, after all. In that case, we could surely distribute blue and white prayer shawls and yarmulkes to all the students. Again, booklets containing the prayers can be printed up and distributed in English and social studies classes. Students and teachers can spend a few days drilling the pronunciation and intonations, and again, full participation in organized school prayer could be achieved in a month—or less. (Again, students who had an objection to participating in Jewish prayer could report to the main office during the ritual.)
Come to think of it, though, it seems the vast, vast majority of those clamoring about school prayer identify themselves as Christians, so it might be that they want organized Christian prayer in school, not just any random spiritual communion with a deity.
No matter, this will actually be easier, because at least the kids’ll be able to pray in English. (We’d have to teach the non-English-speaking kids to recite the words from memory because I doubt the school-praying Christians would want their kids’ ears polluted with prayers in, say, Spanish or anything…
Again, though, the English teacher can be responsible for teaching the prayers, and the guidance office can distribute the rosary beads. The physical education teacher can spend a little time teaching the kids how to make the sign of the cross properly. This all should take even less than a month.
So I’m all for it. Let’s have “prayer in school.” Let’s mandate organized school prayer. What is there to lose?
But, I think I still hear a lot of people complaining that none of the above is what they meant at all. They don’t want prayer. Not really. Not if “prayer” means wearing funny clothes, mumbling in some foreign language, or fiddling with beads. They want “real prayer,” and what they mean by “real prayer,” is of course, the kind of prayer that they do.
In church (not in a synagogue or—gasp—a mosque).
On Sunday (not Saturday or Friday).
They don’t want a moment of quiet spirituality, they want kids participating in their particular brand of religion. And if that’s what they want, then, sorry, I can’t help them. I wouldn’t want to force the Friend to utter his prayers aloud any more than I’d want to snatch rosaries out of the Catholic’s hand or the yarmulke off the Jew’s head.
Prayer is private. Jesus tells his followers to keep it private (“And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men... But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen...” Matthew 6:5-6)
The drafters of the Constitution (or at least of the Bill of Rights) understood the very private nature of one’s faith and one’s expression of that faith, and they deemed that the government would never force a Christian to pray like a Jew or a Muslim like a Christian. I think they also meant that an atheist should not be forced to pray at all.
If you honestly feel that there are times when, and places where, you cannot pray; if you honestly feel you cannot pray without benefit of a court order or federal statute, what does that say about you? What does that say about what you claim to be your faith? What does it say about your relationship with your deity?
Not much, I think.
Now, I’m not taking about prayer in school. Because we’ve always had that. There’ve always been the kids who sit at their table in the cafeteria, hold hands, and say some form of grace before eating their peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. There’ve always been the kids who maybe cross themselves (or whatever their ritual or tradition might be), close their eyes, and mouth a little prayer before their final exam.
I don’t know of any who have been burnt at the stake for having a private, little moment of communion with their deity. They might get stared at; some of their less-enlightened classmates might make an ignorant comment to them, but that’s another issue for another day (“10Blessed are they that are persecuted for righteousness’ sake...11Blessed are ye when men shall revile you …” Matthew 5: 10-11).
Personally, I’ve always thought that the people who complained that they “couldn’t pray” at any given time or place probably weren’t very strong pray-ers to begin with.
But I’m talking about mandated school prayer. I think we should have it. I think we should all write and call our state legislators and demand it. Constitution be damned, every kid in every public school should be required to pray at least once a day.
Given the proper legislation, mandatory, organized school prayer—that so many people on Fox News and the Internet seem to want—could be fully instituted in a month or less.
Here’s a model we could follow:
The Islamic faith has five obligated prayer times, one of which—the noon prayer—occurs during the school day, so this is the one we will adopt. Since the First Amendment guarantees all Muslim students the right to the “free exercise” of their religion, since they have a noon-prayer obligation, and since the supporters of school prayer don’t seem to think there’s any harm in forcing kids to participate in prayer rituals foreign to their own, no one should object to a mandatory noon-prayer break. (Okay, granted, there are those liberals who say that kids who “choose not to participate” in the prayer can absent themselves, so we’ll let those who choose not to participate in this mandatory prayer stand in the hallways or something.)
Booklets explaining the appropriate postures and teaching the words and pronunciations can be distributed in English and social studies classes, and the proper attire can be made available from either the school nurse or the guidance department. With diligence and consistency, within a month, the practice of pausing at noon for organized prayer can be well established in every public school from sea to shining sea.
Of course, it just occurred to me that there might be those with…uh…narrow perspectives, who would object to Islamic prayer in school. We won’t go into what their objections might be, let’s just know that there might be objections—this is America, after all. In that case, we could surely distribute blue and white prayer shawls and yarmulkes to all the students. Again, booklets containing the prayers can be printed up and distributed in English and social studies classes. Students and teachers can spend a few days drilling the pronunciation and intonations, and again, full participation in organized school prayer could be achieved in a month—or less. (Again, students who had an objection to participating in Jewish prayer could report to the main office during the ritual.)
Come to think of it, though, it seems the vast, vast majority of those clamoring about school prayer identify themselves as Christians, so it might be that they want organized Christian prayer in school, not just any random spiritual communion with a deity.
No matter, this will actually be easier, because at least the kids’ll be able to pray in English. (We’d have to teach the non-English-speaking kids to recite the words from memory because I doubt the school-praying Christians would want their kids’ ears polluted with prayers in, say, Spanish or anything…
Again, though, the English teacher can be responsible for teaching the prayers, and the guidance office can distribute the rosary beads. The physical education teacher can spend a little time teaching the kids how to make the sign of the cross properly. This all should take even less than a month.
So I’m all for it. Let’s have “prayer in school.” Let’s mandate organized school prayer. What is there to lose?
But, I think I still hear a lot of people complaining that none of the above is what they meant at all. They don’t want prayer. Not really. Not if “prayer” means wearing funny clothes, mumbling in some foreign language, or fiddling with beads. They want “real prayer,” and what they mean by “real prayer,” is of course, the kind of prayer that they do.
In church (not in a synagogue or—gasp—a mosque).
On Sunday (not Saturday or Friday).
They don’t want a moment of quiet spirituality, they want kids participating in their particular brand of religion. And if that’s what they want, then, sorry, I can’t help them. I wouldn’t want to force the Friend to utter his prayers aloud any more than I’d want to snatch rosaries out of the Catholic’s hand or the yarmulke off the Jew’s head.
Prayer is private. Jesus tells his followers to keep it private (“And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men... But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen...” Matthew 6:5-6)
The drafters of the Constitution (or at least of the Bill of Rights) understood the very private nature of one’s faith and one’s expression of that faith, and they deemed that the government would never force a Christian to pray like a Jew or a Muslim like a Christian. I think they also meant that an atheist should not be forced to pray at all.
If you honestly feel that there are times when, and places where, you cannot pray; if you honestly feel you cannot pray without benefit of a court order or federal statute, what does that say about you? What does that say about what you claim to be your faith? What does it say about your relationship with your deity?
Not much, I think.
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
The Ugly Truth
Well, for a couple of weeks, the entire world seems to have fallen in love with Susan Boyle, the 47-year-old Brit, who stunned everyone with her performance of “I Dreamed a Dream” on Britain’s Got Talent.
Well, not the entire world because the blogosphere is rife with commentaries both praising and panning the woman, her performance, her appearance, the fact that the performance was “staged” or prearranged, and on and on and on...
And, of course, many commentators have picked up the opportunity to criticize “the media” and its skewed values (from the fact that the program was edited, to the fact that Simon Cowell “knew” a woman like Susan Boyle would strike a chord with the general public.)
A couple of things have bothered me about everyone’s reaction.
First of all, I’m bothered that the word ugly has reared its ugly head. Some references mean “ugly” in the sense of “ugly duckling,” while others simply mean “ugly.” I have a problem with both usages.
Let’s face it, the ugly duckling was ugly. As the story goes, he/she/it didn’t possess a beauty that no one noticed or appreciated, he/she/it grew into its beauty. Apparently swan chicks (actually they’re called cygnets) are ugly. So, even appreciating the use of “ugly” as a hyperbole for the sake of an “ugly duckling” metaphor, it’s still grossly unjust to call the woman “ugly.”
In addition, there are those who have simply called the woman ugly. She’s not. She’s really quite average looking. I am reminded of a short play by A. A. Milne of Winnie the Pooh fame. (By the way, I discovered only a few months ago, that Milne was a man. I also learned that his son, Christopher Robin hated him.) Anyway, this play is called “The Ugly Duckling,” and it’s about an “ugly” princess who makes her beautiful maid pretend to be her to court her beautiful suitor. It turns out that the real prince is the “ugly” page. Plain prince and gorgeous page have also switched places in order to woo the princess.
The point of the play is that neither the princess nor the prince is really ugly; they are average-looking. Compared, however, to their fairy-tale-princess-and-prince peers, they are “ugly.” The princess had been granted her ugliness as a gift at her christening by her fairy godmother. If the princess were ugly, the fairy godmother knew, the girl would not grow up pampered and spoiled.
(Anyone see a connection—metaphoric or otherwise—with our society’s powerful Cult of Celebrity, our idolization of “beauty,” and then our dismissal of “average”? It’s almost a powerful enough trend to contribute to young women’s and men’s poor self-images and cause them to develop eating disorders and exercise obsessions, and...oh, wait...)
Anyway, what’s all this got to do with Susan Boyle? Well, like it not, we do base many of our personal judgments on appearance. Shows like 20/20 and Dateline have run a number of episodes over the years about the impact of weight, physical attractiveness, age, dress, etc., on how people are treated in public situations.
The other problem I have with our reaction to Ms. Boyle is how we blame the media for the values both supporters and detractors see exemplified in the whole episode.
The media focuses only on physical appearance and has conditioned us to believe that the average-looking have no value.
The media manipulates us psychologically and emotionally. Susan Boyle was prescreened, and the producers of Britain’s Got Talent (aka Simon Cowell) knew exactly what she would sing and that she would sing it beautifully. The entire segment was edited to highlight the Cinderella-beauty-in-plainness aspect and tug at the heartstrings of the world.
Shame on the media.
I’d like to address the second criticism first. My response is...du-uhhhhh... Of course the performance was screened and the segment edited. That’s what the media does. That’s what we want them to do! Theoretically, the reason we watch television, go to the movies, read books, whatever, is to be “surprised, amused, and delighted.” (Well, I guess there are some people who do watch some news programs with the intent of having their biases and prejudices confirmed rather than challenged, but that is another argument for another day.)
If the media does exactly what we want it to do, and does it all too well, we should not moan and whine, we should applaud!
My response to the first criticism is an extension of this idea. The media is not an entity unto itself; it is a tool, a mirror. Only a fool blames the mirror because he doesn’t like the reflection. So, if we feel convicted because our first inclination was to laugh at this dowdy, middle-aged woman and dismiss the possibility that she might have talent, then that is our conviction. The media only held up the mirror. (I mean, if the media were the least bit interested in shaping society’s values as opposed to merely pandering to them, we would see a lot more originality and a lot less imitation. Eighteen months from now, how many iterations of the “Susan Boyle” phenomenon do you think every broadcast network in the free world will have given us?)
As the Ghost of Christmas Past tells Ebenezer Scrooge in my all-time favorite book, “These are the shadows of things that have been. That they are what they are, do not blame me.”
Imagine the media telling us, “These are the reflections of your attitudes, values, and beliefs. That they are what they are, do not blame us.”
Well, not the entire world because the blogosphere is rife with commentaries both praising and panning the woman, her performance, her appearance, the fact that the performance was “staged” or prearranged, and on and on and on...
And, of course, many commentators have picked up the opportunity to criticize “the media” and its skewed values (from the fact that the program was edited, to the fact that Simon Cowell “knew” a woman like Susan Boyle would strike a chord with the general public.)
A couple of things have bothered me about everyone’s reaction.
First of all, I’m bothered that the word ugly has reared its ugly head. Some references mean “ugly” in the sense of “ugly duckling,” while others simply mean “ugly.” I have a problem with both usages.
Let’s face it, the ugly duckling was ugly. As the story goes, he/she/it didn’t possess a beauty that no one noticed or appreciated, he/she/it grew into its beauty. Apparently swan chicks (actually they’re called cygnets) are ugly. So, even appreciating the use of “ugly” as a hyperbole for the sake of an “ugly duckling” metaphor, it’s still grossly unjust to call the woman “ugly.”
In addition, there are those who have simply called the woman ugly. She’s not. She’s really quite average looking. I am reminded of a short play by A. A. Milne of Winnie the Pooh fame. (By the way, I discovered only a few months ago, that Milne was a man. I also learned that his son, Christopher Robin hated him.) Anyway, this play is called “The Ugly Duckling,” and it’s about an “ugly” princess who makes her beautiful maid pretend to be her to court her beautiful suitor. It turns out that the real prince is the “ugly” page. Plain prince and gorgeous page have also switched places in order to woo the princess.
The point of the play is that neither the princess nor the prince is really ugly; they are average-looking. Compared, however, to their fairy-tale-princess-and-prince peers, they are “ugly.” The princess had been granted her ugliness as a gift at her christening by her fairy godmother. If the princess were ugly, the fairy godmother knew, the girl would not grow up pampered and spoiled.
(Anyone see a connection—metaphoric or otherwise—with our society’s powerful Cult of Celebrity, our idolization of “beauty,” and then our dismissal of “average”? It’s almost a powerful enough trend to contribute to young women’s and men’s poor self-images and cause them to develop eating disorders and exercise obsessions, and...oh, wait...)
Anyway, what’s all this got to do with Susan Boyle? Well, like it not, we do base many of our personal judgments on appearance. Shows like 20/20 and Dateline have run a number of episodes over the years about the impact of weight, physical attractiveness, age, dress, etc., on how people are treated in public situations.
The other problem I have with our reaction to Ms. Boyle is how we blame the media for the values both supporters and detractors see exemplified in the whole episode.
The media focuses only on physical appearance and has conditioned us to believe that the average-looking have no value.
The media manipulates us psychologically and emotionally. Susan Boyle was prescreened, and the producers of Britain’s Got Talent (aka Simon Cowell) knew exactly what she would sing and that she would sing it beautifully. The entire segment was edited to highlight the Cinderella-beauty-in-plainness aspect and tug at the heartstrings of the world.
Shame on the media.
I’d like to address the second criticism first. My response is...du-uhhhhh... Of course the performance was screened and the segment edited. That’s what the media does. That’s what we want them to do! Theoretically, the reason we watch television, go to the movies, read books, whatever, is to be “surprised, amused, and delighted.” (Well, I guess there are some people who do watch some news programs with the intent of having their biases and prejudices confirmed rather than challenged, but that is another argument for another day.)
If the media does exactly what we want it to do, and does it all too well, we should not moan and whine, we should applaud!
My response to the first criticism is an extension of this idea. The media is not an entity unto itself; it is a tool, a mirror. Only a fool blames the mirror because he doesn’t like the reflection. So, if we feel convicted because our first inclination was to laugh at this dowdy, middle-aged woman and dismiss the possibility that she might have talent, then that is our conviction. The media only held up the mirror. (I mean, if the media were the least bit interested in shaping society’s values as opposed to merely pandering to them, we would see a lot more originality and a lot less imitation. Eighteen months from now, how many iterations of the “Susan Boyle” phenomenon do you think every broadcast network in the free world will have given us?)
As the Ghost of Christmas Past tells Ebenezer Scrooge in my all-time favorite book, “These are the shadows of things that have been. That they are what they are, do not blame me.”
Imagine the media telling us, “These are the reflections of your attitudes, values, and beliefs. That they are what they are, do not blame us.”
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
America: Home of the Copycat
Right now, I’m reading Ayn Rand’s The Fountainhead. I don’t really know why; probably because I was looking for a book to read, and “it was there.”
Actually, this is the second time I’ve started this book. I picked it up a few months ago and then put it down to read Alan Paton’s Cry the Beloved Country, which I didn’t read in twelfth-grade English (you know how that goes). When I started …Fountainhead, the first time, the novel annoyed me. Rand has all this “stuff” to say about architecture and modernism versus traditionalism (she’s clearly on the side of modernism). Several of her characters rant about architectural theory. One particularly pompous dunce spouts something to the effect that everything beautiful has already been created; the principles of beauty have already been established, and today’s artists have nothing to do but manipulate them into new arrangements.
As I say, I grew impatient with the book and Rand’s obvious social/philosophical point.
Then I got to thinking about something that has been bothering me for years: why, in our society, do we accept imitation at the expense of innovation? We claim to value creativity in school—in fact, some have argued that we value “creativity” at the expense of “basics.” But that’s another argument for another day.
Still, what evidence can we produce to support our claim that, in society, we really value creativity?
Of the top 10 movies that opened last week (April 10, 2009), and the top 10 hyped as “Coming Soon,” one is the 92nd iteration of the adult-in-kid-body-revisit-the-past-to-change-the-future theme, four are franchise movies (the fourth, or fifth, or fiftieth films in endless series), and three are based on already-popular television series (one a BBC import). Eight of the twenty (40%) reflect more a decision to recycle what is already successful than to test the boundary and encourage creativity.
Broadway is worse. Of the thirty-two plays currently running (or opening within the next few weeks), thirteen (41%) are revivals of previously successful plays. Seven are plays or stage musicals based on already-popular movies. Three are “juke-box musicals” for which storylines were built around already-popular music. And one is a musical based on a popular book based on an even-more popular movie based on a popular series of books. Of thirty-two plays, only eight (25%) are original, first-run offerings by living, breathing, creative playwrights. Of course, that’s an improvement over recent years when none of the Great White Way’s offerings were new. (One was sort-of new, but it had already proven successful in the UK, so it was safe to bring over here.)
And let’s not even start to talk about television. How many “American” TV shows are simply low-quality “adaptations” of popular British shows? How many seasons of The Bachelor and American Idol (which, I believe, is also a British import), and The Apprentice must we sit through? How long can the networks continue to imitate themselves and each other before the once-rich soil is thoroughly depleted, and nothing will grow except re-runs of CSI and House (come to think of it, we’re practically already there)?
I don’t know why this is bothering me now. Maybe it is because the Ayn Rand novel has got me to thinking. Maybe because it’s April, the month during which Hans Christian Andersen, Henry James, Eudora Welty, and William Shakespeare were all born (okay, so Shakespeare recycled most of his plots from classical mythology…but Samuel Beckett, another April playwright, was pretty creative—and he’s currently got a play running on Broadway).
Whatever the reason, it’s something to think about. I’d hate to think that the pompous dean of Rand’s fictional Stanton Institute of Technology is right, that everything has already been created, and all that’s left is to imitate and rearrange.
But I see so little evidence to the contrary these days.
Actually, this is the second time I’ve started this book. I picked it up a few months ago and then put it down to read Alan Paton’s Cry the Beloved Country, which I didn’t read in twelfth-grade English (you know how that goes). When I started …Fountainhead, the first time, the novel annoyed me. Rand has all this “stuff” to say about architecture and modernism versus traditionalism (she’s clearly on the side of modernism). Several of her characters rant about architectural theory. One particularly pompous dunce spouts something to the effect that everything beautiful has already been created; the principles of beauty have already been established, and today’s artists have nothing to do but manipulate them into new arrangements.
As I say, I grew impatient with the book and Rand’s obvious social/philosophical point.
Then I got to thinking about something that has been bothering me for years: why, in our society, do we accept imitation at the expense of innovation? We claim to value creativity in school—in fact, some have argued that we value “creativity” at the expense of “basics.” But that’s another argument for another day.
Still, what evidence can we produce to support our claim that, in society, we really value creativity?
Of the top 10 movies that opened last week (April 10, 2009), and the top 10 hyped as “Coming Soon,” one is the 92nd iteration of the adult-in-kid-body-revisit-the-past-to-change-the-future theme, four are franchise movies (the fourth, or fifth, or fiftieth films in endless series), and three are based on already-popular television series (one a BBC import). Eight of the twenty (40%) reflect more a decision to recycle what is already successful than to test the boundary and encourage creativity.
Broadway is worse. Of the thirty-two plays currently running (or opening within the next few weeks), thirteen (41%) are revivals of previously successful plays. Seven are plays or stage musicals based on already-popular movies. Three are “juke-box musicals” for which storylines were built around already-popular music. And one is a musical based on a popular book based on an even-more popular movie based on a popular series of books. Of thirty-two plays, only eight (25%) are original, first-run offerings by living, breathing, creative playwrights. Of course, that’s an improvement over recent years when none of the Great White Way’s offerings were new. (One was sort-of new, but it had already proven successful in the UK, so it was safe to bring over here.)
And let’s not even start to talk about television. How many “American” TV shows are simply low-quality “adaptations” of popular British shows? How many seasons of The Bachelor and American Idol (which, I believe, is also a British import), and The Apprentice must we sit through? How long can the networks continue to imitate themselves and each other before the once-rich soil is thoroughly depleted, and nothing will grow except re-runs of CSI and House (come to think of it, we’re practically already there)?
I don’t know why this is bothering me now. Maybe it is because the Ayn Rand novel has got me to thinking. Maybe because it’s April, the month during which Hans Christian Andersen, Henry James, Eudora Welty, and William Shakespeare were all born (okay, so Shakespeare recycled most of his plots from classical mythology…but Samuel Beckett, another April playwright, was pretty creative—and he’s currently got a play running on Broadway).
Whatever the reason, it’s something to think about. I’d hate to think that the pompous dean of Rand’s fictional Stanton Institute of Technology is right, that everything has already been created, and all that’s left is to imitate and rearrange.
But I see so little evidence to the contrary these days.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
