Well, for a couple of weeks, the entire world seems to have fallen in love with Susan Boyle, the 47-year-old Brit, who stunned everyone with her performance of “I Dreamed a Dream” on Britain’s Got Talent.
Well, not the entire world because the blogosphere is rife with commentaries both praising and panning the woman, her performance, her appearance, the fact that the performance was “staged” or prearranged, and on and on and on...
And, of course, many commentators have picked up the opportunity to criticize “the media” and its skewed values (from the fact that the program was edited, to the fact that Simon Cowell “knew” a woman like Susan Boyle would strike a chord with the general public.)
A couple of things have bothered me about everyone’s reaction.
First of all, I’m bothered that the word ugly has reared its ugly head. Some references mean “ugly” in the sense of “ugly duckling,” while others simply mean “ugly.” I have a problem with both usages.
Let’s face it, the ugly duckling was ugly. As the story goes, he/she/it didn’t possess a beauty that no one noticed or appreciated, he/she/it grew into its beauty. Apparently swan chicks (actually they’re called cygnets) are ugly. So, even appreciating the use of “ugly” as a hyperbole for the sake of an “ugly duckling” metaphor, it’s still grossly unjust to call the woman “ugly.”
In addition, there are those who have simply called the woman ugly. She’s not. She’s really quite average looking. I am reminded of a short play by A. A. Milne of Winnie the Pooh fame. (By the way, I discovered only a few months ago, that Milne was a man. I also learned that his son, Christopher Robin hated him.) Anyway, this play is called “The Ugly Duckling,” and it’s about an “ugly” princess who makes her beautiful maid pretend to be her to court her beautiful suitor. It turns out that the real prince is the “ugly” page. Plain prince and gorgeous page have also switched places in order to woo the princess.
The point of the play is that neither the princess nor the prince is really ugly; they are average-looking. Compared, however, to their fairy-tale-princess-and-prince peers, they are “ugly.” The princess had been granted her ugliness as a gift at her christening by her fairy godmother. If the princess were ugly, the fairy godmother knew, the girl would not grow up pampered and spoiled.
(Anyone see a connection—metaphoric or otherwise—with our society’s powerful Cult of Celebrity, our idolization of “beauty,” and then our dismissal of “average”? It’s almost a powerful enough trend to contribute to young women’s and men’s poor self-images and cause them to develop eating disorders and exercise obsessions, and...oh, wait...)
Anyway, what’s all this got to do with Susan Boyle? Well, like it not, we do base many of our personal judgments on appearance. Shows like 20/20 and Dateline have run a number of episodes over the years about the impact of weight, physical attractiveness, age, dress, etc., on how people are treated in public situations.
The other problem I have with our reaction to Ms. Boyle is how we blame the media for the values both supporters and detractors see exemplified in the whole episode.
The media focuses only on physical appearance and has conditioned us to believe that the average-looking have no value.
The media manipulates us psychologically and emotionally. Susan Boyle was prescreened, and the producers of Britain’s Got Talent (aka Simon Cowell) knew exactly what she would sing and that she would sing it beautifully. The entire segment was edited to highlight the Cinderella-beauty-in-plainness aspect and tug at the heartstrings of the world.
Shame on the media.
I’d like to address the second criticism first. My response is...du-uhhhhh... Of course the performance was screened and the segment edited. That’s what the media does. That’s what we want them to do! Theoretically, the reason we watch television, go to the movies, read books, whatever, is to be “surprised, amused, and delighted.” (Well, I guess there are some people who do watch some news programs with the intent of having their biases and prejudices confirmed rather than challenged, but that is another argument for another day.)
If the media does exactly what we want it to do, and does it all too well, we should not moan and whine, we should applaud!
My response to the first criticism is an extension of this idea. The media is not an entity unto itself; it is a tool, a mirror. Only a fool blames the mirror because he doesn’t like the reflection. So, if we feel convicted because our first inclination was to laugh at this dowdy, middle-aged woman and dismiss the possibility that she might have talent, then that is our conviction. The media only held up the mirror. (I mean, if the media were the least bit interested in shaping society’s values as opposed to merely pandering to them, we would see a lot more originality and a lot less imitation. Eighteen months from now, how many iterations of the “Susan Boyle” phenomenon do you think every broadcast network in the free world will have given us?)
As the Ghost of Christmas Past tells Ebenezer Scrooge in my all-time favorite book, “These are the shadows of things that have been. That they are what they are, do not blame me.”
Imagine the media telling us, “These are the reflections of your attitudes, values, and beliefs. That they are what they are, do not blame us.”
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment