Right now, I’m reading Ayn Rand’s The Fountainhead. I don’t really know why; probably because I was looking for a book to read, and “it was there.”
Actually, this is the second time I’ve started this book. I picked it up a few months ago and then put it down to read Alan Paton’s Cry the Beloved Country, which I didn’t read in twelfth-grade English (you know how that goes). When I started …Fountainhead, the first time, the novel annoyed me. Rand has all this “stuff” to say about architecture and modernism versus traditionalism (she’s clearly on the side of modernism). Several of her characters rant about architectural theory. One particularly pompous dunce spouts something to the effect that everything beautiful has already been created; the principles of beauty have already been established, and today’s artists have nothing to do but manipulate them into new arrangements.
As I say, I grew impatient with the book and Rand’s obvious social/philosophical point.
Then I got to thinking about something that has been bothering me for years: why, in our society, do we accept imitation at the expense of innovation? We claim to value creativity in school—in fact, some have argued that we value “creativity” at the expense of “basics.” But that’s another argument for another day.
Still, what evidence can we produce to support our claim that, in society, we really value creativity?
Of the top 10 movies that opened last week (April 10, 2009), and the top 10 hyped as “Coming Soon,” one is the 92nd iteration of the adult-in-kid-body-revisit-the-past-to-change-the-future theme, four are franchise movies (the fourth, or fifth, or fiftieth films in endless series), and three are based on already-popular television series (one a BBC import). Eight of the twenty (40%) reflect more a decision to recycle what is already successful than to test the boundary and encourage creativity.
Broadway is worse. Of the thirty-two plays currently running (or opening within the next few weeks), thirteen (41%) are revivals of previously successful plays. Seven are plays or stage musicals based on already-popular movies. Three are “juke-box musicals” for which storylines were built around already-popular music. And one is a musical based on a popular book based on an even-more popular movie based on a popular series of books. Of thirty-two plays, only eight (25%) are original, first-run offerings by living, breathing, creative playwrights. Of course, that’s an improvement over recent years when none of the Great White Way’s offerings were new. (One was sort-of new, but it had already proven successful in the UK, so it was safe to bring over here.)
And let’s not even start to talk about television. How many “American” TV shows are simply low-quality “adaptations” of popular British shows? How many seasons of The Bachelor and American Idol (which, I believe, is also a British import), and The Apprentice must we sit through? How long can the networks continue to imitate themselves and each other before the once-rich soil is thoroughly depleted, and nothing will grow except re-runs of CSI and House (come to think of it, we’re practically already there)?
I don’t know why this is bothering me now. Maybe it is because the Ayn Rand novel has got me to thinking. Maybe because it’s April, the month during which Hans Christian Andersen, Henry James, Eudora Welty, and William Shakespeare were all born (okay, so Shakespeare recycled most of his plots from classical mythology…but Samuel Beckett, another April playwright, was pretty creative—and he’s currently got a play running on Broadway).
Whatever the reason, it’s something to think about. I’d hate to think that the pompous dean of Rand’s fictional Stanton Institute of Technology is right, that everything has already been created, and all that’s left is to imitate and rearrange.
But I see so little evidence to the contrary these days.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment