Thursday, July 2, 2009

With Liberty and Justice for…Whom, Exactly?

What’s up with the Supreme Court these days? Have they simply tossed the concepts of law and justice aside?

I’m not overly concerned with this week’s ruling overturning that decision about the New Haven, CT, firefighters in which Judge Sotomayor participated (as I understand it, she was not the only judge on the case, so the decision was not hers alone). After all, if I’d taken a test to qualify for a promotion and pay raise, passed it, and then was denied the promotion and raise because someone else had failed the test (race and gender aside), I’d be pretty upset.

Gimme the raise I qualified for and fix the test!

Still, the decision does essentially rewrite about forty years of legislative action and legal precedent.

And it’s hard to believe that the 5 – 4 decision was anything but purely political. I mean, come on, who’s trying to discredit whose nomination to the Supreme Court? Sheesh!

And, okay, they did find that that Arizona school district did violate that girl’s rights when they stripped her down to her panties (and then looked inside) to see if she was hiding, like, three ibuprofen tablets.

But I am appalled by their earlier decision, the one where they said that convicts do not have a Constitutional right to have their own DNA tested if they think the test will exonerate them. A person sitting in prison for a crime he (or she) did not commit (let’s face it, how many prisoners would request a DNA test that would prove their guilt?) does not have the right to demand that his (or her) DNA be tested against whatever DNA is in evidence connected with the case even when he (or she) knows that the test will prove his (or her) innocence!!!!!

Here’s a link to one of the many articles about the decision.

Chief Justice Roberts himself wrote (in the decision denying the right to the wrongfully convicted) that DNA testing (as seen on television) has an “unparalleled ability both to exonerate the wrongly convicted and to identify the guilty’’ (emphasis mine). In fact, already some 200+ wrongfully-convicted men (and women) have been so exonerated and released from prison. Even so, we cannot require states to perform to perform the simple test. A convict does not have the right to demand such a test.

It’s better to keep an innocent man (or woman) in prison and to let the truly guilty go free than to…I don’t even know what.

What were those 5 Supreme Court Justices thinking? (Gee, another 5 – 4 split. Same 5? Same 4? Does anyone see a pattern here?)

Anyway, I’ll tell you what those 5 were not thinking; they were not thinking:

“I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me,” (Matthew 25:40 NIV).

They were not thinking:

“Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free,” (John 8: 32 NIV).

Christian principles indeed.

No comments:

Post a Comment