So a few weeks ago, I finally finished reading The Fountainhead. I’d been reading it since, like, April. It was one of those books that, while I was reading it, I was curious enough to find out what was going to happen next; but, once I put the bookmark in and set it down, I was not overly compelled to pick it up again. (That’s pretty much why it took me three months to read the thing.)
Imitating Amazon.com’s five-star reader-rater system, I think I’d have to give this book two stars. (I know, it’s one of those classics, kind of like War and Peace, that carry their own aura of…Oh, you’re reading The Fountainhead! or Wow, you’ve actually read The Fountainhead!)
But I still give it only two stars.
Here’s why:
The plot’s kind of dumb. It’s one of those spanning-years-in-the-lives-of-the-characters books that I usually enjoy, but too much of the plot is predictable. You know that the one guy is going to have a meteoric rise to fame and fortune (and you know he’s going to fall out of favor just as quickly). You know the other guy (the main character) is going to live a miserable, frustrated life. You know that, as soon as the one guy starts to become BFFs with the guy who used to be his enemy that he’s going to betray this new BFF.
You know the one guy is going to get the girl!
Even worse, though, the parts of the plot that weren’t thoroughly predictable were ridiculous in their blatant attempts at being shocking. Now, I’m not opposed to shocking, and good literature should push the envelope, but most of the ostensibly scandalizing elements in The Fountainhead were absolutely without context or motivation—more on that in a minute.
And much of what was intended to be shocking—rough sex, violence, divorce and remarriage—has lost its “punch” since the book was first released in 1943. (I’ve got the DVD starring Gary Cooper and Patricia Neal coming from Netflix, so I’m curious to see how a forties-era movie producer portrayed these elements.) So, what was provocative to my parents is now just silly—especially silly when you know it’s supposed to be outrageous.
In addition to a dumb plot, the novel is populated with dumb characters. Again, Rand is obviously trying to craft new and surprising characters, but in her attempts, she actually creates a whole new stereotype—and all of her characters adhere quite strictly to that stereotype. These are characters who are absolutely unyielding in their intent not to act in their own best interest. Whether the character is a cop-out (like the one who rises meteorically to fame and fortune and gets the girl—at least for a while) or a strong-willed individualist (like the guy who lives the miserable life but gets the girl in the end), none of these characters is motivated by anything real. (Some of them don’t seem to be motivated by anything at all!) Perhaps Rand is trying to create archetypes, but archetypes of what? No one achieves any kind of happiness because no one acts in a way that would foster any kind of happiness.
Perhaps the main character comes the closest because we’re supposed to believe that he doesn’t care. But, then, if he doesn’t care, why should I?
Even “the girl” acts completely without motive—unless her motive is to behave in ways that Rand’s readers will find “shocking.” Ultimately, you don’t really care what happens to any of these characters because none of them has any real emotional or psychological depth.
So, you’ve essentially got a bunch of vapid characters performing a lot of predictably-shocking actions and spouting some philosophy—not exactly a five-star literary experience.
Now, here’s what I did like about the book. Rand’s writing style is really quite beautiful. While most of her images are, again, clichéd—the beautiful, slender woman, leaning against the rail of a yacht, her white dress, fluttering in the tropical breeze; the powerful man, standing like a colossus before a window, the nighttime skyline of New York sparkling behind him—she describes them vividly and beautifully. And, to be fair, perhaps these images weren’t clichés when she devised them in 1943. Again, I’m anxious to see the movie if only to see how director King Vidor translates these images onto the screen.
Maybe I’d be more forgiving of the novel’s shortcomings if it weren’t so heralded as a Great Book—there’s even this huge essay contest with a $10,000 First Prize for high school students. Still, that’s a testimony to the effectiveness of the Ayn Rand institute and nothing else. But, as for originality of plot, effectiveness of things like suspense, irony, etc.; for credible, sympathetic characters; for exploration of ideas, I’m still sticking with my two-star rating.
I did like Anthem, though. Maybe one of these days I’ll tackle Atlas Shrugged.
Friday, July 24, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment