Monday, July 27, 2009

Bad Movie! Bad, Bad Movie!

I really hate it when people don't practice what they preach.

Okay, before I become a preaching hypocrite myself, let me admit that I know we’re all only human, and to hold fast to an ideal is very, very, very difficult (if not outright impossible) in our daily attempts to do as much good as possible and cause as little harm as possible.

But I do hate when highly successful people turn out to have succeeded only at the sacrifice of their...shall I say it?...integrity. You know the kind of person I mean, the Governor who preaches that abstinence is the best and only birth control method (and the only thing teenagers ever need to know about sex), while her own teenaged daughter is … [sigh]; or the Great Religious Leader who rises to national prominence condemning homosexuality while making regular visits to his favorite male prostitute … [sigh]; or the “family values” governor who publicly proclaims that his “soul mate” is a woman in South America, but he will settle for his wife because… [sigh].

And the writer/philosopher who espouses the Great Philosophy of Unyielding Individuality, whose characters say things like, “I don’t build for my clients, I get clients so I can build,” whose climactic moment involves the Unyielding Individualist’s dynamiting a building he’s designed rather than see it bastardized by committee, but sells out her own ideals for a Hollywood contract … [sigh].

I can appreciate the sentiment. There is something lofty and noble about the person who is able to say, “Public be damned, I’m going to do this the way I think it needs to be done.”

Ayn Rand tries to instill this value in her characters. Too bad she doesn't seem able to demonstrate it in her own career.

The Fountainhead, the book, is a two-star attempt at a weakly-plotted philosophical treatise with even weaker characters.

The Fountainhead, the movie, at best exacerbates the flaws of the book and, at worst, enters into a whole new realm of defect. Most movie adaptations of novels—especially adaptations of long novels—are, of necessity, condensations and distillations of the novel on which they are based. Characters are combined, some characters are omitted, plot events are cut short or cut out, time is condensed. Such changes come with the territory, and no one can seriously condemn a movie because it wasn’t absolutely identical to the book on which it was based. (Though we are allowed to admit that “the book was better.”)

In the case of The Fountainhead, however, these condensations and distillations render the movie almost incomprehensible if you haven’t read the book first. The characters in the novel have little enough motivation for their behaviors. In the movie, they have none. A perfect case in point is the character of Ellsworth Toohey, the villain. Rand provides some backstory on Toohey in the novel, and what we learn of his growing up is ostensibly supposed to help us understand the man he becomes. Rand also provides at least a synopsis of the man's rise to power in the novel. He might never quite transcend the stereotype or the cliché, but there is at least an attempt at development. Due to time constraints, however, the Toohey in the film is simply there, arriving in the narrative like Adam in the Garden of Eden—all grown up with no history beyond the day before yesterday. In the novel, when he asks Howard Roark, “What do you think of me?” Roark’s reply has some bite to it because the reader knows that Toohey has been a force behind Roark’s frustrations for a number of years—and Roark knows it too. When Toohey asks the same question in the film, however, the only real reply Roark (and the audience) can offer is, “Who are you, and what is the purpose of this scene?”

Character relationships (vague and unconvincing in the novel) are completely unexplained and unexplored in the film. “You’re engaged to Dominique Francon, aren’t you?” the Powerful Newspaper Mogul asks the Talentless, Spineless Success-story. Someone who’s read the book knows the desired impact of this line, but someone coming fresh to the movie has no idea who Dominique Francon is.

A reader of the novel will also recognize the enormous change from novel to film implicit in this exchange, and this change is a symptom of my strongest criticism of this film.

The novel was released in 1943, the film in 1949. In my earlier post, I described several of the elements of the plot and the characters that were obviously intended to be shocking, things that clearly ran counter to typical 1943-American values: premarital sex, violent sex, adultery, divorce, remarriage, and so on.

One has to admire the challenges Rand must have faced getting her book published and marketed without succumbing to the pressures of censors and public opinion. We know she would not give in because her characters do not give in, and this is what we are supposed to admire about them. This is her Philosophical Message.

There’s even an episode in both the novel and film in which the destitute Roark sacrifices a lucrative contract and refuses to allow one of his buildings to be built rather than accept the modifications to his plan demanded by the clients. And the climactic event in both the book and the movie [spoiler alert: skip to the next paragraph if you really think you’ll read the book or watch the movie and want to be “surprised,”] is Roark’s destruction of a housing development he designed because the design had been altered, and all that he’d demanded was that the project be built exactly as he designed it. His famous speech—which ultimately earns him an acquittal—is all about individual integrity and the danger of compromise.

In Rand’s universe, compromise is bad. Individual integrity is good. One must not yield to public values or tastes, even if that refusal to yield means one will live in obscure poverty. Better to sit alone on a pumpkin than be crowded on a velvet cushion (okay, that’s Thoreau, not Rand, but the philosophies are similar).

Why then, in the translation of book to film, does Rand allow the prevailing values of her day to dictate that she tone down much of what was intended to be shocking in the novel? (And, lest you worry that the novel was adulterated without Rand’s knowledge or consent, be aware that Rand is credited as having written the screenplay herself).

So…when translating book to film, the Unyielding Individualist eliminates all references to divorce. D.F. is not married to P.K., they are “engaged.” She does not embark on a months-long cruise as G.W.’s mistress and then travel to Nevada to divorce P.K. so she can marry G.W. She merely breaks off her engagement. (No adultery, no divorce, no remarriage, no scandal.)

Later, there is no hint of an adulterous affair between D.F. and H.R. And, when they are finally married in the end, she is, again, not divorced but widowed, G.W. having shot himself. (I guess suicide was less shocking to the public sentiment than divorce.)

Of course, without H.R.’s betrayal of G.W., W.’s insistence that R. still build the W-Building loses much of its irony…but, whatever…

So, if it was important in the novel for P.K. and D.F. to be married (to illustrate P.K.’s spinelessness); if it was important for G.W. to essentially buy D.F. from her husband, turn her into his mistress, manipulate her to marry him, etc. (to illustrate his ruthless power and to further emphasize P.K.’s spinelessness), why wasn’t it important to portray these elements in the film?

If we’re supposed to accept Howard Roark’s walking away from a lucrative deal rather than compromise his integrity, if we’re supposed to admire his destroying a building rather than see it bastardized, if we’re supposed to agree that it would be better for the building not to be built than to be built by consensus, then we have to wonder why it was acceptable for Rand to compromise her ideals, to alter aspects of her novel—to “tone them down”—so as not to offend public sensibility.

Wouldn’t it have been better for the movie never to have been made than have its integrity compromised?

Or, conversely, if those elements weren’t crucial to plot and character development, why were they included in the novel? For the sake of sensationalism and titillation?

Looking at the novel and the film, it is difficult to judge whether Ayn Rand is modeling herself after Peter Keating or Gail Wynand; but it is patently clear that she is not Howard Roark.

No comments:

Post a Comment