Wednesday, June 17, 2009

2, 4, 6, 8, Who We Gonna IMITATE?

Okay, so J. D. Salinger, 90 and in poor health, is suing a California-based writer for writing a book whose main character is a 76-year-old Holden Caulfield.

Here's the link to the article I read in the New York Times this morning.

I understand the J.K Rowling thing; the kid who wrote the "guidebook" didn't really contribute anything to the conversation. He just arranged and indexed material Rowling had created.

The Wind Done Gone was, like, a totally different book.

Most recently, there's a novelist making a fortune "borrowing" characters and situations from other writers' works (most famously L. Frank Baum) and recasting them, telling the characters' stories from other viewpoints—you did know that that was what Wicked is all about, right?

I've also read an odd, but not awful, novel—a mystery—whose protagonist is an all-grown-up "Tiny Tim" Cratchit from A Christmas Carol fame. Ebenezer Scrooge puts in a few appearances as well.

Years ago I read Mrs. de Winter, the really, really awful "sequel" to Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca.

Indeed, this whole recasting of other stories, continuing the lives of characters already-made famous, seems to be an industry standard. It almost seems as if you can't get a book published unless it's a rehash of "same-old, same-old."

So we all understand that Salinger is a tad eccentric, and he admirably loves his works and his characters, but I don't see the big deal.

No comments:

Post a Comment